Vendor accountability for HR software.

USE OF SOCIAL SCORING IN HIRING DECISIONS: LEGAL PROHIBITIONS, ALGORITHMIC DISCRIMINATION AND JUDICIAL DEVELOPMENTS

1. INTRODUCTION

Social scoring in hiring refers to the practice of evaluating job applicants through numerical ratings generated from their social behaviour, online activities, personal relationships, communication patterns, digital reputation, political expressions, lifestyle choices, and other behavioural characteristics. Employers may use artificial intelligence, automated recruitment platforms, social media analytics, and predictive algorithms to classify applicants according to perceived reliability, loyalty, personality, cultural compatibility, or organisational suitability.

The legal controversy arises when employers use social scores that are unrelated to professional qualifications or legitimate job requirements. Such practices may produce discrimination, violate privacy, undermine freedom of expression, and create arbitrary barriers to employment.

In Russia, there is no single comprehensive statutory prohibition specifically entitled a prohibition on social scoring in recruitment. Nevertheless, constitutional protections, labour legislation, personal data regulations, and anti-discrimination provisions provide important legal safeguards against abusive social scoring practices.

2. LEGAL FRAMEWORK IN RUSSIA

A. Article 19 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation

Guarantees equality before the law and prohibits discrimination on legally protected grounds. Social scoring systems that indirectly discriminate against applicants may raise constitutional concerns.

B. Article 23 of the Constitution

Protects privacy, personal and family secrets, and confidentiality of communications.

C. Article 24 of the Constitution

Restricts the collection, storage, use, and dissemination of information concerning an individual's private life without the legally required justification or consent.

D. Article 37 of the Constitution

Recognises the right to freely dispose of one's abilities for work and choose an occupation.

E. Article 3 of the Labour Code

Prohibits discrimination in employment based on circumstances unrelated to an employee's professional qualities.

F. Article 64 of the Labour Code

Prohibits unjustified refusal to conclude an employment contract and prohibits direct or indirect restrictions in employment for discriminatory reasons.

G. Article 86 of the Labour Code

Regulates the processing of employees' personal data and establishes requirements concerning the protection of such information.

H. Federal Law No. 152-FZ of 27 July 2006

The Personal Data Law regulates the collection, processing, storage, and use of personal information. Its Article 16 addresses decisions based exclusively on automated processing that produce legal consequences or otherwise significantly affect individuals' rights and legitimate interests.

I. Article 5 of Federal Law No. 152-FZ

Requires personal data processing to be lawful, fair, and limited to specified purposes.

3. MEANING AND TYPES OF SOCIAL SCORING IN RECRUITMENT

Social scoring systems convert personal or behavioural information into numerical assessments used to rank job applicants.

Major forms include:

Social media scoring: Evaluating applicants through public posts, comments, photographs, and online interactions.

Behavioural scoring: Assessing communication patterns, emotional responses, and perceived personality characteristics.

Reputation scoring: Assigning numerical ratings based on online reviews, public controversies, and digital reputation.

Political and ideological scoring: Evaluating applicants through political opinions, affiliations, or public expressions.

Relationship-based scoring: Assessing applicants through their social networks and professional associations.

Lifestyle scoring: Evaluating personal activities, consumption patterns, and private behaviour.

Predictive loyalty scoring: Using algorithms to predict whether applicants may challenge management decisions or leave an organisation.

The central legal problem is that these characteristics may have little or no relationship with an applicant's actual ability to perform the advertised work.

4. IMPORTANT CASE LAWS AND JUDICIAL AUTHORITIES

The following cases provide relevant direct and analogous judicial principles. Comparative European decisions are not automatically binding Russian precedents.

1. Danilenkov and Others v. Russia (European Court of Human Rights, 2009)

Authority: Direct Russian-context authority on employment discrimination.

The case concerned discriminatory treatment of employees because of their trade union membership. The European Court of Human Rights examined the effectiveness of protection against discrimination and the relationship between freedom of association and employment rights.

Relevance: Social scoring that penalises applicants for lawful associations or collective activities may raise similar discrimination concerns. The case supports the principle that employment decisions should not arbitrarily disadvantage individuals because of protected activities.

2. Bărbulescu v. Romania (European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, 2017)

Authority: Analogous authority on workplace privacy.

The case concerned employer monitoring of an employee's electronic communications. The Court examined the balance between workplace management interests and the employee's right to privacy under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Relevance: Extensive monitoring of applicants' digital communications and online behaviour may raise comparable privacy concerns, particularly where monitoring is excessive or insufficiently transparent.

3. López Ribalda and Others v. Spain (European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, 2019)

Authority: Analogous authority on surveillance and privacy.

The case involved covert video surveillance of employees following suspected workplace misconduct. The Court assessed whether the surveillance was justified and proportionate.

Relevance: Employers using automated social media monitoring and behavioural surveillance during recruitment should demonstrate legitimate purposes and proportionality.

4. S. and Marper v. the United Kingdom (European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, 2008)

Authority: Analogous authority on personal data protection.

The case concerned the retention of fingerprints and DNA profiles of individuals who had not been convicted of criminal offences.

The Court found that indiscriminate retention of sensitive personal information violated Article 8.

Relevance: Collecting and permanently retaining extensive personal information for recruitment scoring may create similar concerns regarding excessive data collection, proportionality, and privacy.

5. Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom (European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, 2021)

Authority: Analogous authority on large-scale data surveillance.

The case examined extensive surveillance systems and safeguards governing the interception and processing of communications.

Relevance: Recruitment platforms that systematically collect digital information and construct behavioural profiles should have adequate safeguards against excessive surveillance and misuse.

6. Pihl v. Sweden (European Court of Human Rights, 2017)

Authority: Analogous authority on online information and reputational interests.

The case concerned the publication of an online defamatory comment and the responsibility associated with internet content.

Relevance: Employers should not automatically treat unverified online allegations, anonymous comments, or reputational information as reliable indicators of an applicant's professional suitability.

7. Google Spain SL and Google Inc. v. Agencia Española de Protección de Datos and Mario Costeja González (Court of Justice of the European Union, Case C-131/12, 2014)

Authority: Analogous authority on personal data and online reputation.

The Court of Justice examined the processing of personal information by search engines and the relationship between privacy, data protection, and access to online information.

Relevance: Historical online information should not automatically become a permanent negative recruitment score. Employers should consider accuracy, relevance, context, and applicable data protection requirements.

Jurisdictional qualification: The European Court of Human Rights cases cited above are historical comparative authorities for Russian disputes, subject to the relevant temporal jurisdiction rules. Russia ceased to be a party to the European Convention on Human Rights on 16 September 2022. The CJEU decision is comparative EU authority, not binding Russian law.

5. LEGAL PROHIBITION DEBATES SURROUNDING SOCIAL SCORING

A. DISCRIMINATION THROUGH ALGORITHMIC CLASSIFICATION

An algorithm may disadvantage applicants based on protected characteristics or indirect proxies for those characteristics. For example, residential location, social networks, language patterns, and online activities may produce discriminatory outcomes.

B. PRIVACY AND INFORMED CONSENT

Applicants may not understand what information is collected, how scores are calculated, or how long personal information is retained.

C. AUTOMATED DECISION-MAKING

Article 16 of Federal Law No. 152-FZ restricts decisions based exclusively on automated personal data processing where they produce legal consequences or significantly affect individuals' rights and legitimate interests, subject to statutory exceptions and safeguards.

D. PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS

Article 64 of the Labour Code requires employment decisions to be connected with legitimate employment considerations. Social popularity, personal opinions, and lifestyle preferences generally cannot substitute for relevant professional qualifications.

E. ALGORITHMIC TRANSPARENCY

Applicants may be unable to challenge an adverse decision where employers refuse to disclose the criteria or information underlying automated ratings.

F. REPUTATIONAL MANIPULATION

False information, manipulated online content, and inaccurate digital identities may generate unfair negative scores and undermine equal access to employment.

6. EVIDENTIARY REQUIREMENTS AND EMPLOYER LIABILITY

Applicants challenging social scoring decisions may rely on:

Recruitment platform assessment reports.

Automated ranking and rejection records.

Personal data processing notices.

Emails and internal recruitment communications.

Evidence of discriminatory scoring criteria.

Comparisons between similarly qualified applicants.

Records identifying the data sources used by recruitment algorithms.

Evidence of the absence of human review where legally required.

Under Article 56 of the Russian Civil Procedure Code, parties generally bear the burden of proving the circumstances supporting their claims. Article 67 requires judicial evaluation of evidence.

Potential legal consequences include:

Challenging an unjustified refusal of employment under Article 64 of the Labour Code.

Compensation for proven moral harm under Article 237.

Administrative liability under Article 5.27 of the Code of Administrative Offences where the relevant labour violation is established.

Liability under Article 13.11 of the Code of Administrative Offences for applicable personal data violations.

Other remedies available under personal data and civil legislation.

7. PRACTICAL COMPLIANCE RECOMMENDATIONS

Employers using automated recruitment systems should:

Prohibit social scores based on irrelevant personal characteristics.

Establish clear and lawful purposes for applicant data collection.

Limit personal data processing to information necessary for recruitment.

Provide applicants with legally required information about data processing.

Avoid discriminatory profiling based on political opinions, associations, or private lifestyle.

Establish meaningful human review of significant automated recruitment decisions.

Maintain records of algorithmic criteria and assessment outcomes.

Verify the accuracy and relevance of information obtained from online sources.

Establish procedures for correcting inaccurate applicant information.

Conduct regular audits for discriminatory algorithmic outcomes.

8. CONCLUSION

Social scoring in hiring decisions creates significant legal challenges involving equality, privacy, personal data protection, and fair access to employment. Although Russian legislation does not establish a comprehensive standalone prohibition on every form of recruitment social scoring, Articles 3 and 64 of the Labour Code, Articles 23 and 24 of the Constitution, and Federal Law No. 152-FZ provide important legal safeguards.

The judicial authorities discussed above demonstrate the importance of protecting individuals against discriminatory employment treatment, disproportionate surveillance, and misuse of personal information. In particular, Danilenkov and Others v. Russia provides an important Russian-context authority concerning employment discrimination, while Bărbulescu v. Romania and S. and Marper v. the United Kingdom provide comparative guidance on privacy and personal data protection.

A stronger regulatory framework should require transparency, relevance, proportionality, accuracy, and meaningful human oversight in algorithmic recruitment. Ultimately, hiring decisions should be based on professional competence and legitimate occupational requirements rather than arbitrary numerical assessments of an individual's social reputation or private behaviour.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT