Political Law at Saint Helena, Ascension and Tristan da Cunha (BOT)
Political Law in Saint Helena, Ascension, and Tristan da Cunha (British Overseas Territories)
Saint Helena, Ascension, and Tristan da Cunha are three geographically isolated islands located in the South Atlantic Ocean, and they are part of the British Overseas Territories (BOT). These territories are under British sovereignty but have a significant degree of self-governance. While each of the islands has distinct local governance arrangements, they share a common legal and political framework rooted in the British colonial system, with political law shaped by both the British government and local governments.
1. Constitution and Legal Framework
The political and legal systems of Saint Helena, Ascension, and Tristan da Cunha are defined by a combination of British constitutional law and local law. The overarching legal structure derives from the laws and regulations set by the British government.
Constitutional Framework: The Constitution of Saint Helena, Ascension, and Tristan da Cunha serves as the fundamental legal document for the governance of these territories. This Constitution was enacted in 2009, providing a legal framework for the governance of the territories while maintaining the sovereignty of the United Kingdom.
Governor: Each of these territories is overseen by a Governor appointed by the British monarch on the advice of the British government. The Governor represents the British government and exercises executive powers, including the ability to appoint officials and sign legislation into law. However, the Governor's powers are largely ceremonial and symbolic, with limited intervention in local governance.
Executive Authority: While the Governor holds executive authority, the day-to-day running of the territory is managed by locally elected bodies or councils, depending on the territory. This reflects the territories' degree of self-governance within the British sovereignty framework.
2. Political System and Government Structure
Each of these territories has a unique political structure, but they share similar features related to their status as British Overseas Territories.
Saint Helena
Legislature: The Legislative Council of Saint Helena is the territory’s main legislative body. It consists of a mixture of elected members and appointed representatives. It has 15 members, including 12 elected members who represent the island's districts and 3 appointed members (including the President of the Legislative Council and other officials).
Executive: The Chief Minister is the head of government in Saint Helena. The Chief Minister is elected by the members of the Legislative Council and is responsible for the executive functions of the government. The Chief Minister heads the Executive Council, which includes other government ministers.
Governor's Role: The Governor of Saint Helena retains significant constitutional powers, including the authority to veto bills passed by the Legislative Council and to appoint the Chief Minister.
Ascension Island
Legislature: Ascension Island has a Legislative Council similar to that of Saint Helena. It consists of a smaller number of members, typically including the Administrator (representing the British government), elected members, and appointed officials.
Executive: The Administrator of Ascension Island is the official representative of the British government on the island, while the locally elected Council plays an advisory role in governance. The Administrator also works with the Executive Council to implement the day-to-day governance and policy decisions.
Governor's Role: The Governor of Saint Helena is also responsible for overseeing Ascension Island, though the island has a high degree of self-governance through its local legislative body.
Tristan da Cunha
Legislature: Tristan da Cunha does not have a formal legislature like the other territories, due to its very small population and remote location. The island’s affairs are managed by a Tristan da Cunha Island Council composed of a small number of elected members, including a Mayor and other council members who handle local governance.
Executive: The island is governed by the Island Council, which works in conjunction with the Administrator to make decisions regarding local affairs. The Administrator represents the British government, ensuring that the island adheres to British laws and policies.
Governor's Role: The Governor of Saint Helena also has oversight over Tristan da Cunha, as it is part of the same administrative jurisdiction.
3. Relationship with the United Kingdom
As British Overseas Territories, Saint Helena, Ascension Island, and Tristan da Cunha are self-governing to a certain extent but remain dependent on the United Kingdom for certain matters, particularly defense, foreign policy, and constitutional amendments. The British government retains sovereign authority over the territories, and decisions made by the territories’ governments are subject to the approval of the British government.
Key Areas of British Control:
Foreign Affairs and Defense: The British government is responsible for the foreign relations and defense of these territories. While local governments handle internal matters, the UK Ministry of Defence oversees military and defense issues.
Constitutional Changes: Any significant changes to the Constitution or the status of the territories require approval from the British government.
External Affairs: For example, the territories may consult the British government on matters involving international relations or treaties.
4. Electoral System
Saint Helena
Election of the Legislative Council: Members of the Legislative Council are elected through direct elections by the residents of Saint Helena. The Chief Minister is selected by the elected members of the Legislative Council, and the President of the Legislative Council is elected by the members of the council.
Voting System: The island uses a first-past-the-post electoral system to elect members of the Legislative Council, and elections are held every 5 years.
Ascension Island
Election of the Legislative Council: Ascension Island also holds elections for its Legislative Council, with members being elected by residents of the island.
Voting System: The electoral system is based on direct elections, and the Legislative Council works with the Administrator to manage the governance of the island.
Tristan da Cunha
Election of the Island Council: Tristan da Cunha holds direct elections for its Island Council. The small population means that these elections are relatively informal, with members of the community coming together to elect local leaders.
Voting System: The elections in Tristan da Cunha are more community-oriented, with a small electorate electing representatives for a relatively simple governance structure.
5. Legal System and Judiciary
The legal systems of Saint Helena, Ascension Island, and Tristan da Cunha are based on English common law, with some local modifications. These territories do not have their own legal codes but rely on British law for matters of governance, criminal law, and civil law.
Judicial Authority: Each territory has its own courts, but the ultimate legal authority lies with the British courts, specifically the Privy Council in London, which serves as the highest court of appeal for all the British Overseas Territories.
Local Courts: Each of the territories has a Magistrates’ Court or Island Court to handle local legal matters, including civil and criminal cases.
6. Human Rights and Freedoms
As British Overseas Territories, Saint Helena, Ascension Island, and Tristan da Cunha are bound by international treaties that the United Kingdom has signed, including the European Convention on Human Rights (although the territories are not part of the European Union). The territories also have their own systems for protecting basic human rights, though concerns about freedom of expression, access to justice, and political rights have occasionally been raised due to their isolated nature and small populations.
In practice, the political systems on these islands offer residents a degree of self-governance, but the British government retains control over key areas such as defense and foreign policy.
7. Challenges and Political Issues
Given the small populations and remote locations of these territories, political issues are often tied to practical concerns such as:
Economic Dependence: The territories rely on financial support from the UK, particularly for infrastructure and social services.
Environmental Issues: Environmental protection is a concern due to the territories' rich biodiversity and the challenges posed by their remote locations.
Political Representation: As relatively small communities, there are questions about effective representation in British decision-making processes, especially regarding matters that affect the territories' long-term viability.
Conclusion
The political law of Saint Helena, Ascension Island, and Tristan da Cunha is shaped by their status as British Overseas Territories, with a combination of self-governance and British oversight. These territories have elected representatives and local legislative bodies but remain under the sovereignty of the United Kingdom for issues of defense, foreign policy, and constitutional matters. The Governor represents the British crown, and the political system in each territory is influenced by English common law. While the territories enjoy a degree of autonomy, they remain financially and strategically dependent on the UK, with governance largely focused on local needs and international collaboration with Britain.
RELATED Blog
0 comments