Jurisdiction Shopping In Fintech Licensing .

JURISDICTION SHOPPING IN FINTECH LICENSING: REGULATORY ARBITRAGE, CROSS-BORDER COMPLIANCE AND JUDICIAL CONTROL

1. INTRODUCTION

Jurisdiction shopping in fintech licensing refers to the practice of selecting a particular country or regulatory jurisdiction to establish, license or operate a financial technology business because its regulatory requirements are comparatively favourable. Fintech companies may choose jurisdictions offering lower capital requirements, faster licensing procedures, favourable taxation, flexible digital banking regulations or less restrictive supervisory obligations.

This practice is particularly relevant to digital banks, cryptocurrency exchanges, payment service providers, electronic money institutions, peer-to-peer lending platforms, digital wallets and cross-border financial technology companies.

Although jurisdiction shopping is not inherently unlawful, it becomes problematic when companies deliberately exploit regulatory differences to avoid licensing requirements, circumvent consumer protection rules, weaken anti-money-laundering controls or provide financial services in countries where they lack the required authorisation.

The central legal challenge is balancing regulatory competition and financial innovation against regulatory arbitrage, consumer protection and financial stability.

2. LEGAL FRAMEWORK GOVERNING FINTECH LICENSING

A. EUROPEAN UNION – CROSS-BORDER FINANCIAL LICENSING

The European Union provides a harmonised regulatory environment for several financial services.

Important legislation includes:

Directive 2013/36/EU (Capital Requirements Directive IV) governing credit institutions and banking authorisation.

Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (PSD2) governing payment services.

Directive 2009/110/EC governing electronic money institutions.

Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 (MiCA) governing crypto-asset markets.

Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 (DORA) governing digital operational resilience.

Regulation (EU) 2017/1129 governing prospectus requirements for securities offerings.

Under applicable EU legislation, certain licensed institutions can provide services across member states through passporting arrangements, subject to notification and other regulatory conditions.

However, passporting is not a general exemption from host-state consumer protection, anti-money-laundering or other applicable obligations.

B. SPAIN – FINTECH LICENSING FRAMEWORK

Spain regulates fintech activities through several institutions and legislative instruments.

Important authorities include:

Banco de España: Supervises credit institutions and relevant payment and electronic money institutions.

Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores (CNMV): Supervises securities markets and relevant investment services.

Ministry of Economy: Performs statutory authorisation functions where applicable.

SEPBLAC: Spain's financial intelligence unit responsible for receiving and analysing suspicious financial activity reports.

Relevant legislation includes:

Law 10/2014 on the organisation, supervision and solvency of credit institutions.

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 on payment services and other urgent financial measures.

Law 5/2015 on the promotion of business financing.

Law 10/2010 on the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing.

Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on Markets in Crypto-Assets.

C. UNITED KINGDOM – REGULATORY COMPETITION

The United Kingdom operates a separate fintech licensing framework through the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA).

The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 establishes the principal authorisation framework.

The FCA's regulatory sandbox has also encouraged fintech innovation by allowing eligible firms to test products and services under controlled regulatory conditions.

D. INTERNATIONAL REGULATORY COOPERATION

International financial regulators increasingly cooperate to prevent regulatory arbitrage.

Important institutions include:

Financial Action Task Force (FATF).

Basel Committee on Banking Supervision.

International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO).

Financial Stability Board (FSB).

Their standards encourage supervisory cooperation, transparency, risk-based regulation and cross-border information exchange.

3. METHODS OF JURISDICTION SHOPPING IN FINTECH LICENSING

A. SELECTING LOW-REGULATION JURISDICTIONS

Fintech companies may establish operations in jurisdictions with relatively flexible licensing requirements, lower minimum capital requirements or less demanding supervisory procedures.

However, incorporation in a particular country does not automatically authorise financial services in other jurisdictions.

B. REGULATORY PASSPORTING

Under certain EU financial legislation, authorised institutions can provide services across member states through passporting mechanisms.

Companies may select a member state for initial authorisation based on its regulatory expertise, licensing processes and business environment.

This is lawful when the institution genuinely satisfies the applicable authorisation requirements.

C. CORPORATE STRUCTURING

Fintech groups may establish separate subsidiaries in different jurisdictions to distribute regulatory responsibilities.

For example, a company may locate its technology operations in one country, obtain a payment institution licence in another and target customers in several additional countries.

Regulators examine the actual business model, operational substance and allocation of responsibilities rather than relying exclusively on corporate registration.

D. CRYPTO-ASSET LICENSING ARBITRAGE

Cryptocurrency businesses may seek authorisation in jurisdictions offering favourable crypto regulatory frameworks.

MiCA has reduced certain differences within the EU by establishing common authorisation and passporting requirements for crypto-asset service providers.

E. AVOIDANCE OF HOST-COUNTRY LICENSING

A serious legal problem arises when a fintech company claims that its foreign licence permits it to operate in another country without satisfying that country's local licensing requirements.

The legality depends on the relevant territorial scope of the financial services legislation and applicable cross-border exemptions.

4. IMPORTANT CASE LAWS

1. Fidium Finanz AG v Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht, Case C-452/04 (2006)

The Court of Justice of the European Union considered the provision of financial services by a foreign undertaking to customers in Germany without obtaining the required German authorisation.

The dispute concerned the interaction between the freedom to provide services and national financial licensing requirements.

Legal principle: Member States may impose appropriate authorisation requirements on financial service providers, subject to the applicable EU legal framework.

Relevance: This judgment is important for fintech companies attempting to serve foreign customers through licences obtained in another jurisdiction.

Authority: Direct European financial licensing authority.

2. Alpine Investments BV v Minister van Financiën, Case C-384/93 (1995)

The Court examined restrictions imposed by the Netherlands on financial service providers conducting cross-border activities.

Legal principle: National restrictions on cross-border financial services must be assessed under EU free-movement principles. Measures justified by legitimate public-interest objectives must satisfy proportionality requirements.

Relevance: Provides guidance on the legal limits of national regulatory restrictions affecting international fintech businesses.

Authority: Analogous cross-border financial services authority.

3. Commission v Italy, Case C-518/06 (2009)

The Court of Justice examined the compatibility of national supervisory arrangements with European internal-market obligations.

Legal principle: National supervisory measures must comply with applicable EU law and cannot undermine the effectiveness of harmonised European regulatory arrangements.

Relevance: Supports the principle that fintech licensing and supervision must operate within the broader EU regulatory framework.

Authority: Analogous European regulatory authority.

4. Uber Spain SL v Asociación Profesional Élite Taxi, Case C-434/15 (2017)

The Court examined the legal classification of Uber's platform-based service.

Legal principle: The classification of a digital platform depends on the actual nature of the service and its economic relationship with the underlying activity, rather than simply the technological form of the platform.

Relevance: Although not a banking licensing dispute, the judgment provides an important analytical approach to determining whether a digital business is subject to sector-specific regulation.

Authority: Analogous digital-platform regulatory authority.

5. Google Ireland Ltd and Others v Autorità per le Garanzie nelle Comunicazioni, Case C-376/22 (2024)

The Court considered the compatibility of certain national obligations imposed on digital service providers with the EU framework governing information society services.

Legal principle: Member States cannot automatically extend certain national regulatory obligations to service providers established in another Member State without satisfying the applicable EU legal conditions.

Relevance: Offers guidance on territorial regulatory authority and cross-border digital business operations, although it does not concern fintech licensing directly.

Authority: Analogous cross-border digital regulation authority.

6. Paysera LT UAB v Lietuvos bankas, Case C-389/17 (2019)

The Court of Justice examined the interpretation of electronic money and payment services legislation.

Legal principle: Financial service activities must be classified according to the applicable statutory definitions and the actual economic characteristics of the services.

Relevance: Important for fintech companies selecting jurisdictions and determining whether their activities require payment institution or electronic money authorisation.

Authority: Direct European fintech regulatory authority.

5. LEGAL RISKS ARISING FROM JURISDICTION SHOPPING

A. REGULATORY ARBITRAGE

Companies may exploit differences between national licensing systems to reduce compliance obligations. Such practices can create supervisory gaps and weaken financial stability.

B. MONEY LAUNDERING AND TERRORIST FINANCING

Operating through multiple jurisdictions can complicate customer identification, beneficial ownership verification and suspicious transaction monitoring.

FATF standards seek to strengthen international cooperation and risk-based supervision.

C. CONSUMER PROTECTION

Customers may encounter difficulties obtaining compensation or enforcing their rights when a fintech company operates through a foreign subsidiary.

D. REGULATORY ACCOUNTABILITY

Multiple licensing jurisdictions can create uncertainty regarding which authority is responsible for enforcement, investigations and customer complaints.

E. INSOLVENCY AND DEPOSIT PROTECTION

Cross-border fintech structures may complicate the identification of customer assets, safeguarding arrangements and applicable insolvency proceedings.

6. JUDICIAL AND REGULATORY SAFEGUARDS

Regulators and courts can address unlawful jurisdiction shopping through several mechanisms:

Substance-over-form analysis of corporate structures and financial activities.

Enforcement of local licensing requirements.

Cross-border regulatory information exchange.

Beneficial ownership and anti-money-laundering verification.

Supervision of outsourcing and operational arrangements.

Withdrawal or restriction of authorisation where statutory conditions are satisfied.

Judicial review of disproportionate or unlawful regulatory restrictions.

Under EU law, the home-state and host-state supervisory authorities must cooperate according to the applicable financial services legislation.

7. CONCLUSION

Jurisdiction shopping in fintech licensing is an important issue in modern financial regulation because digital financial businesses can provide services across national borders without maintaining traditional physical banking infrastructure.

Spain and the wider European Union regulate this practice through banking, payment services, electronic money and crypto-asset legislation. European passporting arrangements facilitate legitimate cross-border operations, but they do not permit firms to evade regulatory obligations through artificial corporate structures or misleading licensing claims.

The decisions in Fidium Finanz, Alpine Investments and Paysera demonstrate the importance of lawful licensing, proportionality and accurate classification of financial activities. Meanwhile, Uber Spain and Google Ireland provide useful analogous principles for understanding the territorial regulation of digital businesses.

Ultimately, effective fintech regulation requires a balance between regulatory competition, financial innovation, consumer protection and cross-border supervisory cooperation. Jurisdiction shopping is legitimate when it involves genuine regulatory choice and compliance; it becomes unlawful regulatory arbitrage when used to circumvent mandatory licensing and supervisory requirements.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT