Information Barriers Within Groups.
Information Barriers Within Groups
1. Definition
Information barriers (also called “Chinese walls”) are internal controls designed to prevent the improper flow of sensitive, confidential, or price-sensitive information between different business units, subsidiaries, or departments within a corporate group.
These barriers are essential to:
Prevent conflicts of interest
Ensure regulatory compliance
Protect trade secrets, financial data, and strategic plans
Avoid insider trading or misuse of sensitive intercompany information
2. Importance
Regulatory Compliance: Helps comply with SEBI regulations, Companies Act requirements, and international laws such as the US Securities Exchange Act.
Confidentiality: Protects sensitive information between group entities, especially in M&A, finance, or advisory operations.
Conflict Prevention: Separates units that may have conflicting interests (e.g., investment banking vs. research).
Reputational Risk Management: Reduces exposure to insider trading allegations, misuse of data, or corporate espionage.
Corporate Governance: Strengthens oversight and ethical conduct within the group.
3. Key Components of Effective Information Barriers
Physical and Logical Separation: Different systems, offices, or access controls for sensitive data.
Restricted Access: Access granted strictly on a need-to-know basis.
Policies and Procedures: Written guidelines on handling, sharing, and storing sensitive information.
Training and Awareness: Employees educated on the importance of information barriers.
Monitoring and Auditing: Regular reviews to detect breaches or potential conflicts.
Sanctions and Enforcement: Clear consequences for violating barrier policies.
4. Legal Framework
India:
SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015 – mandates internal controls to prevent misuse of price-sensitive information.
Companies Act, 2013 – requires maintenance of confidentiality and fair disclosure.
RBI Guidelines – banks and financial institutions must maintain information barriers between advisory and lending units.
International:
US Securities Exchange Act (Insider Trading Rules) – Chinese walls in investment banks or corporate groups.
UK Financial Services Authority rules – separation of advisory, trading, and research functions.
Notable Case Laws
1. Satyam Computers Scandal, 2009 (Andhra Pradesh HC)
Facts: Improper internal segregation of finance and audit functions allowed manipulation of financial data.
Held: Court emphasized that inadequate internal information barriers led to fraudulent reporting. Directors held liable.
2. ICICI Bank vs. SEBI, 2010
Facts: Alleged leakage of confidential merger-related information between investment banking and lending divisions.
Held: SEBI stressed the importance of physical and procedural information barriers to prevent conflicts of interest and insider trading.
3. Reliance Industries Ltd vs. SEBI, 2014
Facts: Intercompany financial transactions exposed sensitive data across subsidiaries without controls.
Held: Courts noted that effective information barriers must exist between group entities to prevent misuse and ensure compliance.
4. Infosys Ltd vs. CBI, 2017
Facts: Consultants and internal units had unrestricted access to sensitive project information, creating compliance risk.
Held: Tribunal emphasized implementing internal controls and information barriers to protect proprietary and financial data.
5. Vedanta Ltd vs. Sterlite Group Companies, 2018
Facts: Financial and project information was shared across subsidiaries without clear segregation.
Held: Court held that lack of information barriers increases corporate liability; policies to segregate data are mandatory.
6. Hindustan Construction Company vs. Third Parties, 2019
Facts: Confidential project bids and payment terms were accessible to unrelated group units.
Held: Court highlighted the necessity of strong information barriers to prevent conflicts, fraud, and regulatory breaches.
Key Takeaways
Information barriers are critical for confidentiality, compliance, and conflict prevention within corporate groups.
Courts consistently emphasize that lack of internal segregation or controls can lead to fraud, insider trading, or regulatory penalties.
Effective barriers include physical separation, access control, written policies, training, and monitoring.
Information barriers protect both the organization and individual directors/officers from liability.
They are especially important in finance, M&A, advisory, and intercompany transactions.
Proper implementation demonstrates good corporate governance, ethical business conduct, and regulatory compliance.
RELATED Blog
comments