Illegal Dividend Recovery.
Illegal Dividend Recovery
1. Meaning of Dividend
A dividend is the portion of a company’s profits distributed to its shareholders. Under company law principles (such as those reflected in the Companies Act, 2013), dividends must generally be paid only out of distributable profits or specific reserves permitted by law.
If a company distributes dividends without sufficient profits, from capital, or in violation of statutory provisions, the payment becomes an illegal dividend.
2. What is an Illegal Dividend?
An illegal dividend is a dividend declared or paid contrary to legal requirements, such as:
Payment out of capital rather than profits.
Payment when profits are insufficient.
Payment in violation of statutory rules or articles of association.
Payment without proper declaration by the board or shareholders.
Payment when the company is insolvent or would become insolvent after payment.
Such dividends harm creditors because company capital serves as a protection for them.
3. Recovery of Illegal Dividends
If an illegal dividend has been paid, the company may attempt to recover the amount from shareholders.
However, recovery depends mainly on whether the shareholder knew that the dividend was illegal.
General Rule
If the shareholder received the dividend in good faith and without knowledge of illegality, recovery is usually not allowed.
If the shareholder knew or ought to have known that the dividend was illegal, the company can recover it.
Directors who authorize illegal dividends may also be personally liable.
4. Legal Principles Governing Recovery
(1) Protection of Capital Doctrine
Company capital cannot be returned to shareholders except through lawful procedures (like reduction of capital).
(2) Knowledge of Shareholder
Recovery depends on whether the shareholder had notice or knowledge of the illegality.
(3) Liability of Directors
Directors who knowingly authorize illegal dividends may be liable to compensate the company.
5. Important Case Laws
1. Flitcroft’s Case
Facts:
Directors paid dividends despite the company suffering losses.
Judgment:
The court held that directors are liable for paying dividends out of capital.
Principle:
Directors must ensure dividends are paid only from profits.
2. Re Exchange Banking Co (Flitcroft's Case)
Principle:
This case established that directors who authorize illegal dividends must repay the company for breach of duty.
3. Moxham v Grant
Facts:
Dividends were declared even though profits were not actually available.
Judgment:
The court held that directors must exercise reasonable care and skill before declaring dividends.
Principle:
Directors cannot rely blindly on incorrect financial statements.
4. Bairstow v Queens Moat Houses plc
Facts:
Directors declared dividends when the company had no distributable profits.
Judgment:
Directors were held personally liable for unlawful distribution.
Principle:
A dividend declared without profits constitutes misapplication of company funds.
5. Bond v Barrow Haematite Steel Co
Facts:
A shareholder received dividends later found to be illegal.
Judgment:
The court held that shareholders who received dividends honestly and without knowledge of illegality are not required to repay them.
Principle:
Recovery depends on shareholder knowledge.
6. Re Kingston Cotton Mill Co
Facts:
Dividends were declared based on financial statements prepared by auditors.
Judgment:
Auditors are not expected to detect every fraud, but must act honestly and reasonably.
Principle:
Directors rely on accounts to declare dividends but must still exercise due diligence.
6. Who is Liable in Case of Illegal Dividend?
1. Directors
Directors may be liable if they:
Knowingly declare dividends without profits
Fail to verify financial statements
Breach fiduciary duties
2. Shareholders
Shareholders are liable only if:
They knew the dividend was illegal
They participated in wrongdoing
3. Auditors
Auditors may be liable if:
They negligently certify false accounts
Their negligence leads to illegal dividend declaration
7. Remedies Available
Recovery from directors
Recovery from shareholders (if they knew of illegality)
Compensation for breach of fiduciary duty
Legal action by liquidator if the company goes into liquidation
8. Importance of the Rule
The prohibition of illegal dividends protects:
Company capital
Creditors
Financial stability of the company
Corporate governance standards
✔ Summary:
Illegal dividends occur when a company distributes profits contrary to legal provisions, particularly when paid out of capital or without sufficient profits. Courts generally hold directors liable, while shareholders must repay the dividend only if they knew about the illegality.
RELATED Blog
comments