Hybrid Instrument Regulatory Classification .

HYBRID INSTRUMENT REGULATORY CLASSIFICATION UNDER SPANISH AND EU BANKING LAW

1. Introduction

Hybrid financial instruments are financial products that combine characteristics of two or more traditional financial instruments, particularly debt and equity. They occupy an intermediate position between ordinary borrowing arrangements and conventional ownership interests.

Examples include:

Convertible bonds.

Contingent convertible bonds (CoCos).

Perpetual subordinated debt.

Preference shares.

Participating loans.

Profit-participating securities.

Additional Tier 1 (AT1) capital instruments.

Instruments containing debt-equity conversion mechanisms.

Subordinated bonds with discretionary coupon payments.

Hybrid instruments are particularly important in Spanish and European banking regulation because their classification determines how they are treated for regulatory capital, accounting, investor protection, taxation, insolvency and resolution purposes.

The central legal issue is that an instrument may be classified differently under different regulatory frameworks. For example, an instrument may legally constitute debt under Spanish private law but qualify as Additional Tier 1 capital under prudential banking regulation, while being classified as equity under certain accounting circumstances.

Consequently, regulatory classification must be determined by examining the instrument's contractual rights, economic substance, loss-absorption characteristics and applicable statutory framework.

2. Legal Framework Governing Hybrid Instruments in Spain

Hybrid instrument classification in Spain is governed by a combination of European Union legislation and Spanish national law.

A. Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR)

Regulation (EU) No 575/2013, known as the Capital Requirements Regulation, establishes the prudential treatment of financial instruments issued by banks.

Its relevant provisions include:

Article 26: Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital elements.

Article 51: Additional Tier 1 (AT1) items.

Article 52: Conditions for qualifying as AT1 instruments.

Article 62: Tier 2 capital items.

Article 63: Requirements for Tier 2 instruments.

Article 64: Amortisation of Tier 2 instruments.

Article 52 is particularly important because it establishes the conditions under which hybrid instruments may qualify as AT1 regulatory capital.

These requirements include perpetual maturity, subordination, discretionary distributions and mechanisms for absorbing losses.

The CRR was subsequently amended, including through the Capital Requirements Regulation amendments under Regulation (EU) 2024/1623 (CRR III).

B. Capital Requirements Directive (CRD)

Directive 2013/36/EU establishes the broader prudential supervisory framework for credit institutions.

It provides the institutional framework for:

Capital adequacy.

Supervisory review.

Corporate governance.

Risk management.

Prudential supervision.

Hybrid capital instruments must satisfy the applicable capital eligibility and supervisory requirements.

C. MiFID II

Directive 2014/65/EU on Markets in Financial Instruments (MiFID II) regulates investment services and financial instruments.

Hybrid instruments may fall within the financial instrument categories contained in Section C of Annex I.

MiFID II is relevant to:

Product classification.

Client categorisation.

Suitability and appropriateness assessments.

Disclosure obligations.

Product governance.

Investment advice.

The classification of an instrument as regulatory capital does not remove the issuer's or intermediary's investor-protection obligations.

D. Spanish Securities Markets Law

Law 6/2023 on Securities Markets and Investment Services (Ley 6/2023, de los Mercados de Valores y de los Servicios de Inversión) establishes the Spanish framework implementing and supplementing EU securities-market requirements.

It is relevant to the marketing, distribution and trading of hybrid financial products.

The Spanish National Securities Market Commission (CNMV) supervises relevant investment-service and securities-market conduct.

E. Spanish Banking Law

Law 10/2014 on the Regulation, Supervision and Solvency of Credit Institutions (Ley 10/2014) provides the principal national framework for banking supervision and solvency.

Royal Decree 84/2015 develops important aspects of the regulatory framework.

The Banco de España exercises national banking supervisory responsibilities within the European Single Supervisory Mechanism, while the European Central Bank directly supervises significant institutions.

F. Bank Recovery and Resolution Framework

Directive 2014/59/EU (BRRD) establishes the framework for bank recovery and resolution.

It is particularly important for hybrid instruments because certain subordinated and capital instruments may be subject to:

Write-down.

Conversion into equity.

Bail-in.

Loss allocation.

Resolution-related restructuring.

Spain implemented the framework principally through Law 11/2015 on the recovery and resolution of credit institutions and investment firms.

3. Meaning and Characteristics of Hybrid Financial Instruments

A hybrid instrument combines contractual or economic characteristics traditionally associated with debt and equity.

A. Debt Characteristics

Debt-like characteristics may include:

Contractual payment obligations.

Fixed or variable interest payments.

Principal repayment obligations.

Creditor rights.

Contractual maturity.

Priority over ordinary shareholders in insolvency.

B. Equity Characteristics

Equity-like characteristics may include:

Participation in losses.

Perpetual duration.

Discretionary dividend or coupon payments.

Subordination to ordinary creditors.

Conversion into shares.

Exposure to the issuer's financial performance.

C. Combined Characteristics

Hybrid instruments combine these characteristics.

For example, a contingent convertible bond may initially operate as a debt instrument but automatically convert into equity when the issuer's regulatory capital ratio falls below a specified contractual trigger.

Its legal and regulatory consequences therefore depend on the circumstances in which the instrument operates.

4. Major Categories of Hybrid Instruments

A. Convertible Bonds

Convertible bonds are debt securities that give their holders the right, or sometimes impose an obligation, to convert the outstanding debt into shares.

Their principal features include:

Debt obligations before conversion.

Interest payments, subject to contractual conditions.

Conversion rights.

Potential dilution of existing shareholders.

Equity exposure following conversion.

Regulatory classification depends on the instrument's contractual conditions and the applicable prudential eligibility requirements.

B. Contingent Convertible Bonds (CoCos)

CoCos are hybrid instruments designed to absorb losses when a bank's financial position deteriorates.

They generally contain contractual triggers that cause conversion into equity or principal write-down.

For example, a CoCo may provide that conversion takes place when the issuer's Common Equity Tier 1 ratio falls below a specified threshold.

CoCos are important components of the European banking capital framework.

Their classification as AT1 capital depends on satisfying Article 52 CRR and the other applicable prudential requirements.

C. Additional Tier 1 Instruments

AT1 instruments are hybrid capital instruments recognised under Article 51 and Article 52 CRR.

Typical characteristics include:

Perpetual maturity.

Subordination.

No mandatory contractual redemption in ordinary circumstances.

Discretionary coupon payments.

Loss-absorption mechanisms.

Contractual write-down or conversion arrangements.

AT1 instruments are designed to absorb losses before a bank reaches the point of non-viability.

D. Tier 2 Hybrid Instruments

Tier 2 instruments are subordinated capital instruments that qualify under Articles 62 and 63 CRR.

They generally have a minimum original maturity of five years, subject to the applicable eligibility conditions and amortisation rules.

They are subordinated to ordinary senior creditors and contribute to a bank's regulatory capital.

E. Preference Shares

Preference shares provide shareholders with preferential economic or distribution rights compared with ordinary shares.

However, they may also contain restrictions, discretionary dividends and loss-absorption mechanisms.

Their classification depends on their legal rights, contractual terms and applicable accounting and prudential rules.

F. Participating Loans

Participating loans combine debt financing with remuneration linked to the borrower's financial performance.

Under Spanish Law 10/1996, which introduced provisions concerning participating loans, these instruments have specific legal characteristics.

Article 20 of Royal Decree-Law 7/1996 is particularly relevant.

Participating loans generally have remuneration linked to the borrower's business performance and receive special treatment in specified corporate and insolvency contexts.

They should not automatically be treated as regulatory capital merely because their remuneration is profit-linked.

5. Regulatory Classification Under Different Legal Frameworks

An essential principle is that hybrid instruments do not have one universal classification.

The same instrument may receive different classifications depending on the legal question being examined.

A. Prudential Classification

Under the CRR, regulatory capital is divided into:

Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1).

Additional Tier 1 (AT1).

Tier 2 (T2).

A hybrid instrument can qualify as AT1 or Tier 2 only when the relevant statutory requirements are fulfilled.

The contractual label used by the issuer is not sufficient.

For example, describing a bond as an AT1 instrument does not automatically make it eligible for AT1 capital treatment.

The issuer must demonstrate compliance with the applicable eligibility criteria.

B. Accounting Classification

Accounting classification is primarily governed by International Accounting Standard 32 (IAS 32), Financial Instruments: Presentation.

IAS 32 distinguishes between:

Financial liabilities.

Equity instruments.

The central consideration is whether the issuer has a contractual obligation to deliver cash or another financial asset.

An instrument that requires the issuer to pay cash may generally be classified as a financial liability.

Conversely, an instrument may qualify as equity where the relevant contractual requirements are satisfied.

IAS 32 also recognises compound financial instruments containing both liability and equity components.

For example, a convertible bond may contain:

A debt liability component representing the contractual payment obligations.

An equity component representing a qualifying conversion option.

Therefore, accounting classification is determined by contractual substance rather than simply by the commercial name of the product.

C. Securities Law Classification

Under MiFID II, hybrid instruments may qualify as transferable securities or other financial instruments depending on their structure.

This classification determines the application of investment-service rules.

Financial institutions distributing hybrid instruments must consider:

Whether the product is complex.

Whether the client is retail or professional.

Whether suitability or appropriateness assessments are required.

Whether adequate risk disclosures have been provided.

Whether product governance obligations have been fulfilled.

D. Insolvency Classification

Under Spanish insolvency law, hybrid instruments must be classified according to the applicable creditor-ranking provisions.

The consolidated Insolvency Act (Texto Refundido de la Ley Concursal), approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020, establishes the relevant framework.

Subordinated financial claims generally receive less favourable treatment than ordinary unsecured claims.

The legal ranking depends on the nature of the claim and the applicable statutory provisions.

A hybrid instrument's recognition as AT1 capital does not automatically determine every aspect of its private-law insolvency classification.

E. Tax Classification

Tax treatment may also differ from accounting and prudential classification.

Interest payments may receive different tax treatment from dividends or distributions.

Relevant considerations include:

The legal nature of the instrument.

Whether remuneration constitutes interest or a distribution.

Applicable withholding-tax rules.

Deductibility restrictions.

Related-party financing rules.

Anti-hybrid mismatch provisions.

Spanish corporate taxation is principally governed by Law 27/2014 on Corporate Income Tax.

EU Directive 2016/1164 (ATAD), as amended, also contains anti-hybrid mismatch provisions.

6. Legal Tests for Determining Regulatory Classification

Regulators and courts generally need to examine the substantive characteristics of the instrument.

The following considerations are particularly important.

A. Contractual Rights and Obligations

The first step is to examine the contractual documentation.

Important questions include:

Is repayment of principal legally mandatory?

Can the issuer cancel coupon payments?

Does the investor have voting rights?

Is the instrument convertible?

Is conversion automatic or optional?

Is the instrument perpetual?

Can the issuer redeem it?

The contractual structure provides the starting point for classification.

B. Subordination

Subordination determines the instrument's position relative to other creditors.

An instrument may be subordinated to:

Depositors.

Senior unsecured creditors.

Other subordinated creditors.

The precise ranking depends on the contractual provisions and mandatory insolvency law.

Subordination is particularly relevant to AT1 and Tier 2 eligibility.

C. Loss-Absorption Capacity

Loss absorption is a central feature of regulatory capital instruments.

The regulator examines whether the instrument can absorb losses:

During ordinary business operations.

When specified capital thresholds are breached.

When the institution becomes non-viable.

During resolution proceedings.

An instrument that merely postpones repayment without providing the required loss-absorption mechanism may not qualify for the intended regulatory capital category.

D. Coupon Payment Flexibility

A significant distinction concerns whether coupon payments are mandatory or discretionary.

AT1 instruments must satisfy the relevant CRR requirements concerning distributions.

The issuer must have the contractual ability to cancel distributions in accordance with the applicable requirements.

A mandatory coupon obligation may prevent an instrument from satisfying the relevant AT1 eligibility conditions.

E. Maturity and Redemption

The maturity structure is also important.

AT1 instruments must generally be perpetual.

Tier 2 instruments have different maturity requirements, including the minimum original maturity rule.

The existence of an early redemption option does not automatically disqualify an instrument, but the relevant CRR restrictions must be satisfied.

F. Economic Substance

Regulatory authorities must examine whether the instrument genuinely performs the economic function claimed by the issuer.

An instrument described as equity may operate economically like ordinary debt.

Likewise, an instrument described as debt may contain significant equity-like loss-absorption features.

Economic substance is particularly relevant to accounting, tax and prudential analysis, although each framework has its own legal tests.

7. Regulatory Treatment of Hybrid Instruments in Banking

Hybrid instruments perform several important functions in banking regulation.

A. Capital Adequacy

Banks must maintain minimum capital requirements under the CRR.

Qualifying AT1 and Tier 2 instruments contribute to regulatory capital.

Their recognition helps institutions satisfy applicable capital requirements.

B. Loss Absorption

Hybrid capital is intended to protect depositors and other senior creditors by absorbing losses before ordinary resolution or insolvency outcomes arise.

C. Resolution Planning

Under the BRRD, qualifying instruments may be affected by resolution measures.

The resolution authority may impose write-down or conversion measures in accordance with the applicable statutory hierarchy and conditions.

D. Market Discipline

Hybrid capital investors are exposed to greater risks than ordinary senior creditors.

This exposure is intended to create incentives for investors to monitor the issuer's financial condition.

E. Investor Protection

The complexity of hybrid products requires strong disclosure and distribution controls.

Banks must not present high-risk capital instruments as equivalent to ordinary deposits or low-risk savings products.

8. Role of Spanish Regulatory Authorities

A. Banco de España

The Banco de España performs national prudential supervisory functions within the European banking supervisory framework.

Its responsibilities include:

Monitoring regulatory capital.

Supervising credit institutions within its competence.

Assessing compliance with banking legislation.

Monitoring risk management.

Supporting the implementation of prudential requirements.

B. European Central Bank

The ECB directly supervises significant credit institutions under the Single Supervisory Mechanism.

It assesses prudential compliance and the capital position of supervised banks.

C. Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores

The CNMV supervises securities markets and relevant investment-service activities.

Its responsibilities are particularly important where hybrid financial instruments are marketed to investors.

D. FROB

The Fund for Orderly Bank Restructuring (FROB) performs functions under Spain's bank recovery and resolution framework.

Hybrid instruments may become relevant during restructuring and resolution proceedings.

9. Important Case Laws

The following judgments provide important legal principles concerning hybrid instruments, financial-product classification, investor protection and bank resolution.

Case 1: Kotnik and Others v Državni Zbor

Case C-526/14, Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union, 19 July 2016.

Facts:

The case concerned Slovenian banking-sector restructuring and the application of State aid rules to banks experiencing financial difficulties.

The restructuring involved burden-sharing measures affecting shareholders and subordinated creditors.

Legal Issue:

Whether subordinated creditors could be required to contribute to bank restructuring before State aid was granted.

Judgment:

The CJEU examined the compatibility of burden-sharing requirements with EU State aid law and fundamental rights.

It recognised the importance of shareholders and subordinated creditors bearing losses before public financial assistance is provided, subject to the applicable legal safeguards.

Legal Principle:

Subordinated capital instruments may be exposed to loss allocation during bank restructuring.

The contractual and regulatory position of hybrid capital investors must therefore be examined in light of the applicable State aid and resolution framework.

Relevance to Spain:

The judgment is relevant to Spanish banking restructuring because Spain operates within the EU State aid and bank-resolution framework.

Case 2: Ledra Advertising Ltd and Others v European Commission and ECB

Joined Cases C-8/15 P to C-10/15 P, Judgment of 20 September 2016.

Facts:

The dispute arose from the financial assistance programme for Cyprus and the restructuring of Cypriot banks.

The measures affected deposits and financial claims as part of the banking-sector restructuring.

Legal Issue:

Whether EU institutions could incur non-contractual liability in connection with measures adopted during the financial assistance programme.

Judgment:

The CJEU examined the responsibility of EU institutions and the protection of fundamental rights.

It confirmed that EU institutions remain bound by fundamental rights when acting within the framework of financial assistance programmes.

Legal Principle:

Financial restructuring does not eliminate the requirement to comply with applicable fundamental rights and legal safeguards.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

The judgment is important when assessing the legality of restructuring measures affecting financial investors and subordinated claims.

Case 3: Genil 48 SL and Comercial Hostelera de Grandes Vinos SL v Bankinter SA and Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA

Case C-604/11, Judgment of 30 May 2013.

Facts:

The dispute concerned interest-rate swap transactions entered into by customers with financial institutions.

The customers alleged that the banks had failed to comply with applicable investment-service obligations.

Legal Issue:

Whether investment firms were required to comply with suitability and appropriateness obligations when providing investment services involving financial instruments.

Judgment:

The CJEU interpreted the investor-protection obligations under the MiFID framework.

It explained the distinction between suitability and appropriateness assessments and the circumstances in which they apply.

Legal Principle:

Financial institutions must comply with the applicable investor-protection requirements when distributing financial instruments.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

Banks marketing CoCos, preference shares and other complex hybrid products must consider their MiFID obligations, including suitability and appropriateness requirements where applicable.

Case 4: Banif Plus Bank Zrt v Márton Lantos and Mártonné Lantos

Case C-312/14, Judgment of 3 December 2015.

Facts:

The case involved foreign-currency lending and financial transactions connected with a banking relationship.

Legal Issue:

The CJEU considered the distinction between certain banking and lending activities and investment services involving financial instruments under MiFID.

Judgment:

The Court clarified the scope of the relevant investment-service provisions and the treatment of particular banking transactions.

Legal Principle:

Not every banking transaction involving financial risk automatically constitutes an investment service under MiFID.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

Classification must be based on the legal nature of the transaction and the applicable statutory definition, rather than simply on the existence of financial risk.

Case 5: Andriciuc and Others v Banca Românească SA

Case C-186/16, Judgment of 20 September 2017.

Facts:

The dispute concerned foreign-currency loan agreements and the risks associated with exchange-rate fluctuations.

Legal Issue:

Whether contractual terms allocating currency risks complied with the transparency requirements of EU consumer-protection law.

Judgment:

The CJEU explained that contractual terms must be drafted in a manner allowing consumers to understand their potential economic consequences.

Legal Principle:

Transparency requires more than formal linguistic clarity. Consumers must be able to assess the potentially significant economic consequences of contractual terms.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

This principle is relevant to the disclosure of conversion triggers, coupon cancellation, principal write-down and other risks embedded in complex hybrid products distributed to retail investors.

Case 6: Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino

Case C-618/10, Judgment of 14 June 2012.

Facts:

The dispute concerned consumer credit and the judicial examination of potentially unfair contractual terms.

Legal Issue:

The CJEU examined the effectiveness of consumer protection under Directive 93/13/EEC.

Judgment:

The Court reinforced the requirement that national courts ensure effective protection against unfair consumer-contract terms.

Legal Principle:

Consumer protection cannot be undermined by contractual arrangements or procedural rules that make enforcement of consumer rights ineffective.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

Where hybrid instruments are distributed through consumer-facing financial arrangements, the applicable consumer-protection rules must be considered alongside securities legislation.

Case 7: Bankia SA v Individual Investors

Spanish Supreme Court, Judgment No. 840/2013, 20 January 2014.

Facts:

The litigation concerned the sale of preference shares and related financial products to investors.

Investors challenged the validity of their consent, alleging that material information about the financial product had not been adequately disclosed.

Legal Issue:

Whether the misrepresentation of relevant financial information could invalidate the investors' contractual consent.

Judgment:

The Spanish Supreme Court addressed the legal consequences of material errors in consent in the context of the financial product distribution dispute.

Legal Principle:

The marketing of complex financial instruments requires adequate disclosure of their essential characteristics and risks.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

The judgment is particularly important for preference shares and similar hybrid products sold to retail customers.

It demonstrates that contractual documentation and regulatory classification do not automatically establish that the investor received adequate information.

Case 8: Spanish Supreme Court Judgment No. 244/2013, 18 April 2013

Facts:

The dispute concerned financial swap agreements and the information supplied to customers.

Legal Issue:

Whether inadequate information about the financial risks of a complex financial product could produce a legally relevant error in consent.

Legal Principle:

The financial institution's information obligations must be assessed in light of the complexity of the product and the customer's understanding.

Relevance to Hybrid Instruments:

The judgment provides useful guidance on the importance of clear disclosures concerning the economic consequences of complex financial contracts.

10. Classification Problems and Regulatory Challenges

A. Conflicting Legal Classifications

A hybrid instrument may qualify as debt under private law but as regulatory capital under the CRR.

This creates potential conflicts between:

Contractual rights.

Accounting treatment.

Prudential capital treatment.

Insolvency ranking.

Tax classification.

The solution is to apply the legal test relevant to each regulatory framework independently.

B. Unclear Coupon Cancellation Clauses

Certain hybrid instruments contain complicated coupon cancellation provisions.

Uncertainty may arise regarding whether cancellation is genuinely discretionary or whether the issuer remains subject to an enforceable payment obligation.

Such uncertainty can affect AT1 eligibility.

C. Ambiguous Conversion Triggers

Conversion provisions may contain unclear capital thresholds or valuation mechanisms.

Ambiguity can produce disputes regarding:

The timing of conversion.

The relevant capital ratio.

The calculation methodology.

Investor rights following conversion.

D. Inadequate Investor Disclosure

Investors may incorrectly assume that hybrid bonds offer the same protection as ordinary deposits or senior debt.

This creates significant mis-selling risks.

E. Regulatory Arbitrage

Financial institutions may attempt to structure instruments in ways that obtain favourable regulatory or accounting treatment without satisfying the substantive policy objectives of the applicable rules.

Supervisors therefore examine contractual substance and compliance with eligibility conditions.

F. Cross-Border Classification Differences

An instrument issued in one EU Member State may be distributed in another.

Differences in national corporate law, insolvency law and tax treatment may create uncertainty.

EU prudential and securities-market rules reduce some of these differences, but they do not eliminate every national-law distinction.

11. Regulatory Compliance Requirements for Spanish Banks

Spanish banking institutions issuing or distributing hybrid instruments should maintain a comprehensive compliance framework.

Important requirements include:

Legal review of the instrument's contractual documentation.

Confirmation of eligibility under the relevant CRR provisions.

Appropriate accounting classification under IAS 32.

Compliance with applicable MiFID II requirements.

Clear disclosure of coupon and conversion risks.

Appropriate client categorisation.

Suitability or appropriateness assessments where required.

Accurate regulatory capital reporting.

Monitoring of conversion and loss-absorption triggers.

Compliance with BRRD and applicable resolution requirements.

Appropriate internal governance and risk controls.

Periodic reassessment of regulatory eligibility.

12. Practical Example

Assume that a Spanish bank issues a perpetual subordinated bond with the following terms:

Nominal value: EUR 1,000.

Annual coupon: 7%.

Coupon payments may be cancelled under specified contractual conditions.

The instrument is subordinated to senior creditors.

The principal may be written down when a specified CET1 trigger is reached.

The instrument has no ordinary contractual maturity.

The bank describes the product as an AT1 hybrid capital instrument.

The regulatory analysis would proceed as follows:

Step 1: Private-law classification

Examine whether the instrument creates a debt claim under the applicable Spanish corporate and contractual law.

Step 2: Prudential classification

Determine whether the instrument satisfies Article 52 CRR and all other applicable AT1 eligibility requirements.

Step 3: Accounting classification

Examine the coupon obligations, redemption provisions and other contractual features under IAS 32.

Step 4: Securities-law classification

Determine whether the instrument qualifies as a financial instrument under MiFID II and identify the applicable investor-protection obligations.

Step 5: Insolvency classification

Determine the instrument's ranking under the applicable Spanish insolvency and contractual rules.

Step 6: Resolution treatment

Determine whether and how the instrument may be written down or converted under the BRRD and Spanish implementing legislation.

The conclusion is that the instrument may qualify as AT1 capital without necessarily being classified as equity for every other legal purpose.

13. Relationship Between Hybrid Classification and Financial Stability

Hybrid instruments contribute to financial stability by providing additional loss-absorbing capacity.

They help reduce the likelihood that banking-sector losses will immediately require public financial assistance.

However, they also create regulatory and investor-protection risks.

If hybrid instruments are incorrectly classified, banks may report inaccurate regulatory capital positions.

If their contractual conditions are unclear, investors may misunderstand the possibility of coupon cancellation or principal loss.

Consequently, accurate classification is essential for:

Banking-sector solvency.

Investor confidence.

Financial-market transparency.

Effective bank resolution.

Protection of depositors.

Reduction of systemic risk.

14. Conclusion

Hybrid instrument regulatory classification is a multidimensional legal process under Spanish and EU banking law.

The classification of an instrument cannot be determined solely by its commercial name or the description used by the issuing institution.

Instead, authorities must examine the contractual structure, repayment obligations, coupon arrangements, subordination, conversion rights, loss-absorption mechanisms and applicable statutory requirements.

The CRR establishes the principal prudential requirements for AT1 and Tier 2 capital. IAS 32 governs the accounting distinction between liabilities and equity. MiFID II governs relevant investment-service and investor-protection obligations. Spanish insolvency legislation determines the applicable treatment of claims in insolvency, while the BRRD governs relevant write-down and conversion measures during bank resolution.

The judgments in Kotnik, Ledra Advertising, Genil 48, Andriciuc and the Spanish Bankia preference-share litigation demonstrate the importance of substantive classification, regulatory compliance, transparency and investor protection.

Ultimately, the governing principle is that hybrid instruments must be classified according to the specific legal framework being applied, taking account of their contractual substance and economic function. No single classification automatically determines their treatment for every purpose under Spanish and EU law.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT