Hybrid Financing Instruments Classification Rules

 

HYBRID FINANCING INSTRUMENTS CLASSIFICATION RULES – SPAIN AND EUROPEAN UNION LAW

1. Introduction

Hybrid financing instruments are financial arrangements that combine characteristics of both debt and equity. They are designed to provide financing to companies, financial institutions, banks and investment entities while offering features associated with both borrowing and ownership.

A conventional debt instrument creates an obligation to repay borrowed money, usually with interest. Equity financing, on the other hand, represents an ownership interest in a company and generally provides returns through dividends or distributions.

Hybrid financing instruments combine these characteristics. For example, a company may issue preference shares that provide fixed returns but also contain contractual redemption obligations. Similarly, subordinated debt may offer interest payments while absorbing losses during financial distress.

In Spain, the classification of hybrid financing instruments is important under:

Spanish company law.

Spanish corporate income tax law.

Spanish accounting standards.

European Union financial services legislation.

Banking capital adequacy regulations.

Insolvency and resolution legislation.

International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).

The fundamental principle is that the legal and economic substance of an instrument must be examined rather than relying exclusively on its contractual title.

2. Meaning and Characteristics of Hybrid Financing Instruments

A hybrid financing instrument is a financial instrument containing elements of both debt and equity.

Common characteristics include:

Fixed or variable returns.

Contractual redemption rights.

Subordination to ordinary creditors.

Participation in company profits.

Conversion into ordinary shares.

Loss-absorption mechanisms.

Deferred interest or dividend payments.

Perpetual or long-term maturity.

For example, a Spanish company may issue preference shares carrying a fixed annual return of 6%. However, payment may depend on the availability of distributable profits, and the shares may rank behind ordinary creditors during liquidation.

Although the instrument resembles debt because of its fixed return, it may qualify as equity under the applicable accounting rules because the issuer has no contractual obligation to repay cash.

3. Main Types of Hybrid Financing Instruments

A. Preference Shares

Preference shares provide shareholders with preferential rights concerning dividends or distributions of company assets.

They may contain:

Fixed dividend entitlements.

Priority over ordinary shareholders.

Limited voting rights.

Cumulative or non-cumulative dividends.

Redemption provisions.

Conversion rights.

Their classification depends on their contractual characteristics.

If the issuer has an unconditional contractual obligation to deliver cash, the instrument may be classified as a financial liability under IAS 32.

If the issuer has no contractual obligation to deliver cash and the instrument represents a residual ownership interest, it may qualify as equity.

B. Convertible Bonds

Convertible bonds are debt instruments that allow or require conversion into shares under specified conditions.

They contain two possible financial components:

A debt component representing the contractual obligation to pay interest and principal.

An equity component representing the conversion option, where the relevant conditions for equity classification are satisfied.

Under IAS 32, a conventional convertible bond may therefore require separation into liability and equity components in the issuer's financial statements.

C. Subordinated Debt

Subordinated debt ranks below senior unsecured creditors in the payment hierarchy.

It is commonly used by financial institutions to strengthen regulatory capital.

Characteristics include:

Lower priority during insolvency.

Long-term maturity.

Contractual interest payments.

Possible restrictions on repayment.

Potential loss-absorption features.

Subordinated debt generally remains debt for accounting purposes unless its contractual terms establish an equity instrument. However, qualifying subordinated instruments may be recognised as regulatory capital under the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR).

D. Perpetual Bonds

Perpetual bonds have no fixed maturity date.

They may provide periodic interest payments, but repayment of principal is not necessarily required on a predetermined date.

Depending on their contractual terms, perpetual bonds may qualify as:

Financial liabilities.

Equity instruments.

Additional Tier 1 regulatory capital instruments.

The absence of a maturity date alone does not automatically make an instrument equity.

E. Profit-Participating Loans

Profit-participating loans provide returns linked to the profits, turnover or performance of the borrower.

In Spain, these arrangements are particularly relevant under Article 20 of Royal Legislative Decree 7/1996.

Profit-participating loans may include:

Variable interest linked to business performance.

Additional fixed interest.

Subordination arrangements.

Early repayment restrictions.

Long-term financing provisions.

They are legally loans, although certain Spanish corporate law and insolvency rules give them special treatment.

F. Contingent Convertible Bonds (CoCos)

Contingent convertible bonds are hybrid instruments commonly issued by banks.

They may convert into equity or suffer principal write-down when specified regulatory capital triggers are reached.

Their principal purpose is to absorb losses and strengthen the bank's capital position during financial distress.

Qualifying Additional Tier 1 instruments must satisfy the requirements of the CRR, particularly Articles 51 and 52.

4. Legal Framework Governing Hybrid Financing Instruments in Spain

The Spanish legal framework combines domestic legislation with directly applicable European Union regulations.

A. Spanish Companies Act

Royal Legislative Decree 1/2010, approving the Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital), establishes the legal framework governing share capital, shareholder rights and corporate financing.

Relevant provisions include:

Article 273 – Application of Profits

This provision regulates the distribution of company profits and establishes restrictions on dividend distributions.

Preference shares and other equity-like instruments must comply with applicable distributable-profit requirements.

Article 275 – Distribution of Dividends

This provision governs the allocation of dividends among shareholders, subject to the company's constitutional documents and applicable statutory requirements.

Articles 98–103 – Redeemable Shares

These provisions regulate redeemable shares in Spanish corporations, including their issuance and redemption conditions.

These rules are relevant when a hybrid instrument includes redemption rights or preferential shareholder entitlements.

B. Spanish Corporate Income Tax Law

Law 27/2014 on Corporate Income Tax (Ley del Impuesto sobre Sociedades) is particularly important for determining the tax treatment of hybrid financing instruments.

Article 15 – Non-Deductible Expenses

Article 15 establishes categories of expenses that cannot be deducted for corporate income tax purposes.

It is important when examining payments under instruments classified as equity or when dealing with financial arrangements designed to create tax-deductible interest without corresponding taxable income.

Article 15 bis – Asymmetric Hybrid Mismatches

Article 15 bis implements EU hybrid mismatch rules.

It addresses situations where differences in the legal or tax classification of financial instruments between jurisdictions produce:

Deduction without inclusion.

Double deductions.

Other specified hybrid mismatch outcomes.

The provision is particularly important for cross-border financing arrangements involving Spanish companies and foreign related entities.

Article 16 – Interest Deduction Limitation

Article 16 limits the deductibility of net borrowing costs, generally by reference to 30% of operating profit, subject to statutory adjustments, exceptions and the applicable minimum deduction threshold.

This rule is relevant where a hybrid instrument is treated as debt for Spanish tax purposes.

C. Spanish General Accounting Plan

The Spanish General Accounting Plan (Plan General de Contabilidad), approved by Royal Decree 1514/2007, establishes accounting principles for financial instruments.

Its provisions require examination of the contractual rights and obligations arising from financial arrangements.

The accounting classification of a hybrid instrument must reflect its economic and contractual substance.

For companies applying EU-adopted IFRS, IAS 32 and IFRS 9 are particularly relevant.

5. International Financial Reporting Standards: IAS 32

IAS 32, Financial Instruments: Presentation, is one of the most important standards for classifying hybrid financing instruments.

The standard distinguishes between:

Financial liabilities.

Equity instruments.

Compound financial instruments.

A. Financial Liability Classification

An instrument generally qualifies as a financial liability where the issuer has a contractual obligation:

To deliver cash or another financial asset.

To exchange financial assets or liabilities under potentially unfavourable conditions.

For example, a bond requiring repayment of principal after five years generally constitutes a financial liability.

B. Equity Classification

An instrument may qualify as equity where it represents a residual interest in the assets of an entity after deducting all its liabilities.

For example, ordinary shares without mandatory redemption obligations generally qualify as equity.

C. Compound Financial Instruments

IAS 32 requires separate presentation of the liability and equity components of certain compound financial instruments.

A conventional convertible bond illustrates this approach.

The issuer must identify:

The present value of contractual debt obligations.

The residual value attributable to the qualifying equity conversion option.

This separation ensures that financial statements properly reflect the economic structure of the transaction.

6. IFRS 9 and Classification of Hybrid Financial Assets

IFRS 9 governs the recognition and measurement of financial assets and financial liabilities.

For financial assets, classification generally depends on:

The entity's business model for managing the financial asset.

The contractual cash flow characteristics of the instrument.

The principal measurement categories include:

Amortised cost.

Fair value through other comprehensive income (FVOCI).

Fair value through profit or loss (FVTPL).

A debt instrument may qualify for amortised cost measurement where the relevant business model and contractual cash flow tests are satisfied.

An instrument containing contractual cash flows that are not solely payments of principal and interest generally fails the SPPI test and is measured at FVTPL, subject to the detailed IFRS 9 requirements.

Equity investments are generally measured at fair value, with a limited irrevocable election for certain non-trading investments to present changes in fair value in other comprehensive income.

These rules are particularly relevant where hybrid instruments contain profit participation, conversion rights or derivative features.

7. European Union Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR)

The Capital Requirements Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 establishes prudential requirements for banks and investment firms within its scope.

It provides a separate regulatory classification framework for bank capital.

Three principal categories are recognised:

A. Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1)

CET1 represents the highest-quality regulatory capital.

It generally includes:

Ordinary shares meeting regulatory conditions.

Share premium accounts.

Retained earnings.

Certain qualifying reserves.

Article 26 identifies the principal elements of CET1.

B. Additional Tier 1 (AT1)

AT1 instruments are designed to absorb losses while the institution remains a going concern.

Article 51 identifies the elements of Additional Tier 1 capital.

Article 52 establishes the eligibility requirements.

Important requirements include:

Direct issuance by the institution.

Full payment of the instrument.

Subordination to relevant creditors.

Perpetual maturity.

Discretion over distributions.

Loss-absorption provisions.

No contractual features that undermine the instrument's regulatory capital characteristics.

C. Tier 2 Capital

Tier 2 instruments are designed to provide additional loss-absorbing capacity, particularly in resolution or insolvency.

Articles 62 and 63 of the CRR establish the relevant eligibility requirements.

Qualifying subordinated debt may constitute Tier 2 capital.

Importantly, regulatory capital classification is different from ordinary accounting classification. An instrument may be a financial liability under IAS 32 while qualifying as AT1 or Tier 2 capital under the CRR.

8. EU Anti-Hybrid Mismatch Rules

The EU has introduced anti-hybrid mismatch provisions through the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD) and ATAD II.

The principal legislation is:

Directive (EU) 2016/1164.

Directive (EU) 2017/952.

These directives address tax mismatches arising from differences in the classification of financial instruments and entities between jurisdictions.

A. Deduction Without Inclusion

This occurs when one jurisdiction permits a tax deduction for a payment but the recipient jurisdiction does not include the corresponding amount in taxable income within the relevant period.

B. Double Deduction

A double deduction occurs when the same payment or expenditure is deducted in two different jurisdictions.

C. Imported Hybrid Mismatches

Imported mismatch rules prevent taxpayers from benefiting indirectly from hybrid mismatch arrangements through transactions involving other jurisdictions.

D. Spanish Implementation

Article 15 bis of Law 27/2014 implements important hybrid mismatch provisions in Spain.

The provision requires analysis of the classification of the relevant financial instrument in the jurisdictions concerned and the resulting tax treatment.

Its application is particularly important for multinational corporate groups, cross-border subsidiaries and international treasury structures.

9. Classification Tests for Hybrid Financing Instruments

The classification of a hybrid financing instrument should be conducted through a structured legal and financial assessment.

Test 1: Contractual Repayment Obligation

The first question is whether the issuer is contractually required to repay principal.

Mandatory repayment generally indicates liability classification.

Test 2: Nature of Returns

The next question is whether returns are:

Fixed interest.

Discretionary dividends.

Profit-linked distributions.

Contingent payments.

The nature of the return helps identify the instrument's debt or equity characteristics.

Test 3: Subordination

The ranking of the instrument against other creditors must be examined.

Deep subordination may support regulatory capital eligibility but does not automatically convert debt into equity.

Test 4: Conversion Rights

The classification must consider whether conversion into ordinary shares is mandatory, optional or contingent.

The settlement provisions and fixed-for-fixed requirements under IAS 32 are especially relevant.

Test 5: Maturity and Redemption

A fixed maturity date and mandatory redemption generally indicate debt characteristics.

Perpetual maturity and discretionary redemption may support equity-like treatment.

However, the complete contractual terms must be considered.

Test 6: Loss Absorption

The instrument must be examined for contractual write-down, conversion and loss-absorption mechanisms.

These features are particularly important for regulatory capital classification.

Test 7: Tax Treatment

The tax treatment must be separately assessed under Spanish domestic law and applicable international tax rules.

An instrument treated as equity for accounting purposes may not necessarily receive identical treatment under every applicable tax rule.

Test 8: Substance and Anti-Abuse Considerations

Authorities may examine whether the structure has been designed to create artificial tax advantages or circumvent regulatory requirements.

The legal form of an instrument cannot automatically determine every regulatory or tax consequence.

10. Important Case Laws

The following judgments are relevant to the interpretation of financial instruments, investor protection, bank capital and hybrid financing arrangements. Not every judgment directly determines the accounting classification of a hybrid instrument; their relevance must be understood within their respective legal contexts.

Case 1: Kotnik v Državni zbor

Court of Justice of the European Union, Case C-526/14, Judgment of 19 July 2016

This case concerned the compatibility of bank burden-sharing requirements with EU State aid rules.

The Court considered the treatment of shareholders and subordinated creditors when a bank receives State support.

The judgment examined the relationship between bank recapitalisation, subordinated financial instruments and the protection of investors.

Legal principles:

Shareholders and subordinated creditors may be required to contribute to bank restructuring before State aid is granted.

Burden-sharing measures must comply with applicable EU legal principles.

Investors in subordinated instruments may be exposed to losses.

EU State aid rules must be considered when restructuring financial institutions.

Relevance to hybrid financing:

The judgment is important for subordinated debt, preference shares and hybrid capital instruments issued by financial institutions.

It demonstrates that contractual ranking and loss-absorption provisions have significant consequences during banking distress.

Case 2: Genil 48 SL and Comercial Hostelera de Grandes Vinos SL v Bankinter SA and Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA

CJEU, Case C-604/11, Judgment of 30 May 2013

This case concerned investment services and financial instruments under the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive.

The Court examined the scope of investment advice and the regulatory obligations applicable to financial institutions.

Legal principles:

Investment services must be classified according to the relevant EU regulatory definitions.

Financial institutions must comply with applicable conduct-of-business obligations.

The provision of investment advice must be assessed by reference to the actual service supplied.

Relevance to hybrid financing:

Hybrid instruments are often complex financial products.

Their distribution may involve investment advice, suitability requirements and investor-protection obligations under MiFID II.

The judgment is therefore relevant to the regulatory treatment and marketing of hybrid financial products.

Case 3: Banif Plus Bank Zrt v Márton Lantos and Mártonné Lantos

CJEU, Case C-312/14, Judgment of 3 December 2015

The case concerned foreign exchange transactions associated with a foreign-currency loan and the scope of EU financial markets legislation.

The Court examined whether the relevant foreign exchange operations fell within the definition of financial instruments under the applicable MiFID framework.

Legal principles:

Financial transactions must be classified according to the statutory definitions applicable to them.

Not every transaction involving foreign exchange automatically constitutes a regulated financial instrument.

The contractual and economic characteristics of the transaction are relevant.

Relevance to hybrid financing:

The judgment supports the need to distinguish between different financial products by examining their actual contractual characteristics rather than relying on commercial descriptions.

Case 4: Andriciuc and Others v Banca Românească SA

CJEU, Case C-186/16, Judgment of 20 September 2017

This case concerned foreign-currency loan agreements and the transparency requirements under EU consumer-protection legislation.

The Court examined the importance of consumers understanding the economic consequences of contractual foreign-exchange risk.

Legal principles:

Contractual terms must be sufficiently transparent.

Consumers must be able to understand the potentially significant economic consequences of financial obligations.

The assessment of contractual transparency must consider the information available to consumers when entering into the agreement.

Relevance to hybrid financing:

Where hybrid instruments are offered to retail investors, the complexity of their repayment, conversion and loss-absorption mechanisms makes disclosure particularly important.

Case 5: Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino

CJEU, Case C-618/10, Judgment of 14 June 2012

The case concerned unfair terms in consumer contracts and the powers of national courts under Directive 93/13/EEC.

The Court examined the obligations of national courts when dealing with potentially unfair contractual terms.

Legal principles:

Consumer-protection rules require effective judicial protection.

National courts must examine unfair contractual terms in accordance with EU law.

Contractual arrangements cannot escape consumer-protection requirements merely because they are presented as standard financial agreements.

Relevance to hybrid financing:

The judgment is relevant when hybrid financial products are sold to consumers through standard-form contractual documentation.

Case 6: Banco Popular Resolution – European Union General Court

General Court, Cases T-481/17 and related Banco Popular litigation

The Banco Popular resolution litigation concerned the resolution of a Spanish banking institution under the EU Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive.

The proceedings examined the legality of resolution-related decisions and the rights of investors affected by the resolution.

Legal principles:

Bank resolution operates within the statutory framework established by EU resolution legislation.

Shareholders and holders of certain capital instruments may suffer losses during resolution.

Regulatory decisions must comply with applicable procedural and substantive legal requirements.

Relevance to hybrid financing:

The litigation is significant for understanding the exposure of shareholders and holders of subordinated and hybrid capital instruments during bank resolution.

11. MiFID II and Investor Protection

Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II) regulates investment services and activities.

Hybrid financing instruments may fall within the scope of MiFID II depending on their legal characteristics.

Important requirements include:

Client classification.

Suitability assessments.

Appropriateness assessments.

Product governance.

Risk disclosure.

Conflict-of-interest management.

Best execution obligations where applicable.

Complex hybrid securities may require particular attention because investors may misunderstand their loss-absorption, conversion or redemption provisions.

Spanish implementation is primarily contained in the Spanish Securities Markets and Investment Services Law 6/2023 and its applicable implementing regulations.

12. Hybrid Financing and Spanish Insolvency Law

Spanish insolvency law is principally governed by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020, approving the consolidated text of the Insolvency Law.

The classification of hybrid financing instruments is particularly important during insolvency proceedings.

The relevant issues include:

Whether the financing constitutes an ordinary or subordinated claim.

Whether the creditor has a contractual security interest.

Whether the instrument is legally classified as equity.

Whether the financing qualifies for special statutory treatment.

Whether payments may be challenged under insolvency avoidance provisions.

Profit-Participating Loans

Spanish law provides special treatment for profit-participating loans.

Article 20 of Royal Legislative Decree 7/1996 is particularly relevant.

It provides for the subordination of qualifying profit-participating loans in insolvency and establishes specific rules governing their treatment.

The classification of these instruments must therefore consider both their contractual form and the statutory consequences applicable to them.

13. Regulatory Challenges in Classifying Hybrid Financing Instruments

Several practical difficulties arise in Spain and the European Union.

A. Divergent Accounting and Tax Classification

An instrument may be classified as equity under accounting standards but receive different treatment under tax legislation.

This may create tax asymmetry and require examination under Article 15 bis of the Spanish Corporate Income Tax Law.

B. Cross-Border Classification Conflicts

Different countries may classify the same instrument differently.

For example, a preference share may be treated as equity in one jurisdiction and debt in another.

Such differences can produce hybrid mismatch outcomes.

C. Regulatory Capital Eligibility

A financial instrument may resemble equity economically but fail to satisfy the technical eligibility requirements for CET1 or AT1 capital.

Regulatory classification must therefore be independently established under the CRR.

D. Investor Misunderstanding

Retail investors may mistakenly assume that preference shares or subordinated bonds carry the same repayment protection as ordinary bank deposits.

Financial institutions must ensure that relevant risks are properly disclosed.

E. Insolvency and Resolution Risks

The contractual ranking of hybrid instruments determines the potential exposure of investors during insolvency and bank resolution.

F. Financial Engineering and Regulatory Arbitrage

Complex contractual structures may be used to achieve favourable accounting, tax or regulatory outcomes.

Supervisory authorities must assess whether these structures satisfy the applicable legal requirements.

14. Practical Example

Assume that a Spanish banking institution issues a €100 million perpetual bond with the following conditions:

No fixed maturity date.

Annual distribution of 7%.

Distributions may be cancelled at the issuer's discretion.

The instrument ranks behind senior creditors.

Principal is written down when a specified regulatory capital trigger is reached.

The instrument satisfies the applicable CRR eligibility requirements.

The classification would be examined as follows:

Accounting classification: The contractual terms must be assessed under IAS 32. If the issuer has no contractual obligation to deliver cash, equity classification may be appropriate.

Prudential classification: If all Article 52 CRR requirements are satisfied, the instrument may qualify as Additional Tier 1 capital.

Tax classification: The treatment of distributions must be examined under Spanish corporate tax legislation, including the relevant provisions of Law 27/2014.

Insolvency and resolution: The instrument's contractual subordination and statutory loss-absorption characteristics determine its treatment in the relevant proceedings.

Investor protection: Its distribution and marketing must comply with applicable MiFID II requirements.

This example demonstrates that one financial instrument may have different classifications for different legal purposes.

15. Recommendations for Spanish Financial Institutions

Spanish financial institutions and corporate issuers should adopt a comprehensive classification framework.

Recommended measures include:

Conduct a contractual review before issuing hybrid instruments.

Prepare separate accounting, tax and prudential classification assessments.

Examine all redemption and conversion clauses.

Verify regulatory capital eligibility under the CRR.

Assess potential hybrid mismatch consequences under Article 15 bis of Law 27/2014.

Maintain proper documentation of the classification analysis.

Provide transparent investor disclosures.

Review cross-border tax consequences.

Monitor changes in EU banking and financial services legislation.

Reassess classification whenever contractual terms are amended.

16. Conclusion

Hybrid financing instruments occupy an important position in modern Spanish and European financial markets because they combine characteristics of debt and equity.

Their classification cannot be determined exclusively by their commercial name or the description used in the financing agreement.

Instead, the classification must be assessed separately under the applicable company law, accounting standards, corporate tax rules, banking capital regulations, securities legislation and insolvency framework.

IAS 32 provides the principal accounting distinction between financial liabilities and equity instruments, while IFRS 9 governs the recognition and measurement of financial instruments.

The CRR establishes specific eligibility requirements for CET1, AT1 and Tier 2 regulatory capital. Meanwhile, Article 15 bis of Spanish Law 27/2014 addresses cross-border hybrid mismatch arrangements.

The CJEU's judgments in Kotnik, Genil 48, Banif Plus Bank and Andriciuc provide important legal principles concerning banking resolution, financial instrument regulation and investor protection.

Ultimately, a legally sound hybrid financing classification requires a substance-based examination of contractual obligations, repayment rights, loss absorption, subordination, conversion provisions and the regulatory purpose of the instrument.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT