Governance Practices In Acquired Entities.
Governance Practices in Acquired Entities
1. Introduction
Governance practices in acquired entities refer to the frameworks, policies, and oversight mechanisms that guide the management, accountability, and compliance of a company that has been acquired in a merger or acquisition (M&A).
Effective governance is crucial for:
Ensuring regulatory compliance
Protecting shareholder rights
Maintaining operational integrity
Facilitating post-merger integration
Poor governance in acquired entities can lead to legal liabilities, operational failures, and reputational damage for the acquiring company.
2. Importance of Governance Practices in Acquired Entities
Regulatory Compliance:
Alignment with corporate laws, listing rules, and cross-border regulations is essential.
Board and Management Oversight:
Ensures that the board exercises fiduciary duties and monitors management performance.
Transparency and Disclosure:
Accurate financial and operational reporting prevents fraud and mismanagement.
Integration Success:
Harmonized governance practices reduce conflicts and improve decision-making post-acquisition.
Risk Mitigation:
Strong governance minimizes exposure to legal, operational, and reputational risks.
3. Key Governance Practices in Acquired Entities
A. Board Structure and Composition
Review the composition of the board, including independent directors, executive directors, and committee roles.
Ensure alignment with the acquiring company’s governance policies.
B. Audit and Risk Management
Evaluate internal audit practices, risk management frameworks, and financial controls.
Align risk monitoring systems post-acquisition.
C. Compliance and Ethics
Assess compliance programs, anti-bribery policies, and whistleblower mechanisms.
Standardize ethical codes of conduct across the merged entity.
D. Reporting and Disclosure
Review accounting policies, regulatory filings, and reporting systems.
Ensure compliance with local and international reporting standards.
E. Shareholder and Stakeholder Rights
Protect minority shareholders and other stakeholders.
Harmonize dividend, voting, and dispute resolution mechanisms.
4. Challenges in Governance of Acquired Entities
Cultural Misalignment:
Differences in governance culture between acquiring and acquired companies.
Regulatory Conflicts:
Cross-border acquisitions may involve conflicting governance standards.
Legacy Practices:
Outdated policies, weak internal controls, or informal decision-making structures.
Fiduciary Risk:
Misalignment of board roles may expose directors to liability.
Stakeholder Resistance:
Minority shareholders or employees may resist governance changes.
5. Governance Assessment in Acquisitions
Step 1: Pre-Acquisition Governance Due Diligence
Assess board composition, committee structures, and fiduciary practices.
Review regulatory compliance history and prior litigations.
Step 2: Governance Integration Planning
Align board and management oversight with acquiring company.
Harmonize policies on audit, risk management, and ethics.
Step 3: Implementation and Monitoring
Appoint or restructure board and committees.
Standardize reporting, compliance programs, and internal controls.
Monitor effectiveness of governance practices post-integration.
6. Case Laws on Governance Practices in Acquired Entities
Case 1: Tata Steel Ltd. v. Corus Group PLC
Issue: Board and employee representation post-acquisition
Observation: UK corporate governance standards required Tata to honor Corus board and employee consultation obligations
Lesson: Pre-acquisition due diligence must evaluate board composition, employee representation, and governance compliance
Case 2: Vodafone International Holdings B.V. v. Hutchison Essar
Issue: Board restructuring and minority shareholder rights post-acquisition
Observation: Courts emphasized protection of minority rights and proper board composition
Lesson: Governance practices must protect shareholder rights and comply with regulatory norms
Case 3: Infosys Ltd. v. SEBI
Issue: Independent director requirements and committee composition
Observation: SEBI mandated alignment of governance practices with listing and disclosure requirements
Lesson: Regulatory compliance is critical in governance practices of acquired entities
Case 4: GlaxoSmithKline Plc v. SmithKline Beecham Plc
Issue: Board committees and reporting misalignment in post-merger integration
Observation: Misaligned governance delayed regulatory reporting and operational decisions
Lesson: Proper integration of committees, audit, and risk oversight is essential
Case 5: Reliance Industries Ltd. v. BP Plc
Issue: Joint venture governance and board oversight
Observation: Court upheld shareholder agreements defining board composition, veto powers, and fiduciary duties
Lesson: Governance practices must respect contractual rights and strategic control mechanisms
Case 6: Daimler-Benz AG v. Chrysler Corporation
Issue: Cross-border governance misalignment in a “merger of equals”
Observation: Different governance philosophies led to operational inefficiencies
Lesson: Harmonization of governance practices is critical in cross-border acquisitions
Case 7 (Additional): Facebook, Inc. v. Instagram
Issue: Board oversight and governance alignment post-acquisition
Observation: Required compliance with cross-border regulatory frameworks and fiduciary duties
Lesson: Governance practices in acquired entities must consider regulatory and fiduciary obligations
7. Best Practices for Governance in Acquired Entities
Conduct Thorough Governance Due Diligence
Assess boards, committees, policies, and regulatory compliance.
Harmonize Board and Committee Structures
Align audit, risk, nomination, and remuneration committees.
Standardize Policies and Codes of Conduct
Ethics, anti-bribery, whistleblower policies, and internal controls.
Ensure Regulatory and Legal Compliance
Compliance with listing rules, corporate laws, and cross-border regulations.
Protect Shareholder and Stakeholder Rights
Ensure mechanisms for minority shareholder protection and stakeholder engagement.
Monitor and Review
Post-integration governance audits and board effectiveness reviews.
8. Key Takeaways
Governance practices in acquired entities are crucial for risk management, operational integrity, and regulatory compliance.
Poor governance can lead to legal liabilities, operational inefficiencies, and shareholder disputes.
Case law highlights the importance of:
Board and committee alignment
Independent director compliance
Minority shareholder protection
Post-merger governance integration
RELATED Blog
comments