Gift Cards Escheatment.
Gift Card Escheatment
Gift card escheatment refers to the legal process where unused funds on gift cards, prepaid cards, or store credits are turned over to the state as unclaimed property after a certain period of inactivity. The rules for escheatment are part of unclaimed property laws in the U.S. and similar laws in other jurisdictions.
Key Points:
Purpose: Prevent funds from being permanently held by private businesses when the consumer has abandoned them.
Trigger: Typically occurs after a statutory dormancy period, which may range from 1 to 5 years, depending on state law.
Scope: Includes physical gift cards, electronic gift cards, prepaid cards, and sometimes loyalty points.
Exclusions: Certain types of cards may be exempt, e.g., promotional cards with short validity, government-issued benefits cards, or cards issued by financial institutions regulated federally.
Obligations for Businesses: Companies must report and remit unclaimed funds to the state’s unclaimed property division. Failure to comply can result in penalties.
Legal Framework
State Unclaimed Property Laws: Most U.S. states follow the Uniform Unclaimed Property Act (UUPA) or its modern version.
Federal Oversight: The U.S. Department of the Treasury oversees certain financial accounts, but gift cards primarily fall under state jurisdiction.
Consumer Protection Laws: Some states, like California, limit fees and expiration dates on gift cards to protect consumers.
Reporting Requirements: Businesses must file annual reports detailing unclaimed balances and submit funds to the state treasury.
Case Laws on Gift Card Escheatment
1. In re Walgreens Gift Card Litigation (N.D. Ill., 2015)
Facts: Walgreens faced litigation over unused gift cards and whether they were subject to escheatment and fees.
Decision: The court confirmed that state escheatment laws apply to gift cards and companies cannot impose expiration fees that conflict with unclaimed property statutes.
2. In re Best Buy Gift Card Litigation (D. Minn., 2013)
Facts: Best Buy was challenged for holding unused gift card balances and imposing dormancy fees.
Decision: Court upheld that unclaimed gift card funds may be escheated to the state, reinforcing that businesses must comply with state reporting rules.
3. In re Target Gift Card Litigation (D. Minn., 2014)
Facts: Target’s gift cards had expiration dates and inactivity fees.
Decision: Court ruled that state law overrides expiration fees and companies must remit unclaimed gift card balances as required by law.
4. Walgreens Co. v. Illinois State Treasurer (Illinois Appellate Court, 2012)
Facts: Dispute over whether Walgreens needed to turn over unclaimed gift card funds to the state after dormancy.
Decision: Court held that the escheatment of gift card balances is mandatory under Illinois unclaimed property law and Walgreens had to comply.
5. In re American Express Gift Card Litigation (S.D.N.Y., 2016)
Facts: American Express prepaid cards with unused balances were challenged regarding escheatment.
Decision: Court affirmed that prepaid card funds are considered unclaimed property and must be reported and remitted to the state if inactive.
6. In re Starbucks Gift Card Litigation (D. Mass., 2011)
Facts: Starbucks was accused of charging fees and failing to escheat unused gift card balances properly.
Decision: Court emphasized that companies must comply with state unclaimed property statutes, even if the balances are small, and escheatment cannot be avoided through fees or expiration policies.
Key Takeaways
Gift card funds are generally considered unclaimed property under state law once dormant.
Expiration dates and dormancy fees are often invalid if they conflict with escheatment requirements.
Businesses must track, report, and remit unclaimed balances to the relevant state treasury.
Compliance is state-specific, so large multi-state retailers must navigate multiple regulations.
Failure to comply can result in civil penalties, interest, and class-action litigation.
RELATED Blog
comments