Foreign Investment In Llps
1. Legal Nature of LLPs and Relevance for Foreign Investment
A Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) is a hybrid entity combining:
Operational flexibility of partnerships
Limited liability of companies
Under Indian law, LLPs are treated distinctly from companies for FDI and FEMA purposes, and foreign investment in LLPs is permitted but conditional.
2. Statutory and Regulatory Framework
(a) Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008
Governs incorporation, management, and partner liability
Foreign entities and individuals can be partners subject to FEMA compliance
(b) Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA)
Regulates capital account transactions
Foreign contribution to LLP capital is a regulated activity
(c) Consolidated FDI Policy (DPIIT)
Specifically addresses FDI in LLPs
Distinguishes LLP investment from company investment
(d) FEMA (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019
Provides legal backing to LLP FDI conditions
Prescribes reporting and pricing guidelines
3. Permissibility of Foreign Investment in LLPs
Foreign investment in LLPs is permitted only if all the following conditions are met:
The LLP operates in a sector where:
100% FDI is permitted
Automatic route is available
There are no FDI-linked performance conditions
The LLP does not operate in prohibited sectors
Examples of prohibited sectors include:
Multi-brand retail
Atomic energy
Gambling and betting
Real estate business (with limited exceptions)
4. Entry Route and Mode of Investment
(a) Entry Route
Automatic route only (subject to sector eligibility)
Government approval route generally not available for LLPs
(b) Mode of Investment
Capital contribution
Acquisition or transfer of profit-sharing ratio
No issuance of instruments analogous to equity shares
5. Downstream Investment by LLPs
An LLP with foreign investment:
Is considered a foreign-owned or controlled entity
Can make downstream investments only in compliance with sectoral caps and entry routes
Must ensure compliance on a look-through basis
Downstream non-compliance attracts FEMA violations.
6. Conversion Between Company and LLP
(a) Company to LLP Conversion
Permitted only if:
The company operates in sectors eligible for LLP FDI
There is no violation of FDI conditions
Conversion does not result in breach of sectoral caps
(b) LLP to Company Conversion
Allowed subject to:
FEMA pricing and reporting compliance
No circumvention of sectoral restrictions
7. Pricing, Valuation, and Reporting Compliance
Capital contribution and transfer must follow fair valuation norms
Reporting through RBI’s FIRMS portal
Timely filing of Form LLP(I) and LLP(II)
Non-reporting constitutes a FEMA contravention.
8. Taxation Interface
LLPs are taxed as partnerships
Foreign partners are subject to:
Withholding tax on profit distribution
Permanent establishment considerations
Tax compliance does not dilute FEMA requirements.
9. Judicial Interpretation and Case Law Analysis
Case 1: Vodafone International Holdings BV v. Union of India
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Substance of investment structure prevails over form
Relevance:
Applied to LLP FDI structuring and beneficial ownership analysis.
Case 2: Union of India v. Hindustan Development Corporation
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Economic policy decisions merit judicial deference
Relevance:
Supports restrictive conditions on LLP FDI.
Case 3: R.K. Garg v. Union of India
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Economic legislation enjoys presumption of constitutionality
Relevance:
Upholds sector-specific limitations on LLP investments.
Case 4: Essar Steel Ltd. v. Union of India
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Strategic sector regulation lies within executive discretion
Relevance:
FDI restrictions applicable equally to LLPs.
Case 5: Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union of India
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Courts avoid interference in matters of economic policy
Relevance:
LLP FDI eligibility criteria are policy-driven.
Case 6: Tata Sons Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Corporate structuring cannot be used to defeat regulatory intent
Relevance:
Prevents misuse of LLP structures to bypass FDI norms.
Case 7: IDBI Trusteeship Services Ltd. v. Hubtown Ltd.
Supreme Court of India
Principle:
Commercial arrangements subject to regulatory compliance
Relevance:
Applied to capital contribution and control in LLPs.
10. Compliance Risks and Consequences
Non-compliance may result in:
FEMA penalties and compounding
Forced restructuring or divestment
Invalidation of downstream investments
Personal liability of designated partners
11. Best-Practice Compliance Strategy
Sector eligibility analysis before structuring
Conservative interpretation of “performance conditions”
Clear partner agreements aligned with FEMA
Robust reporting calendar
Ongoing monitoring of downstream investments
12. Conclusion
Foreign investment in LLPs is permitted but tightly circumscribed. Indian courts and regulators consistently affirm that:
LLPs are not a loophole for FDI circumvention
Sectoral policy overrides entity choice
Substance prevails over form
Foreign investors and Indian promoters must therefore adopt a policy-aligned, compliance-first approach when using LLP structures.
RELATED Blog
comments