Dividend Payout Policy Governance
Dividend Payout Policy Governance: Detailed Explanation
A dividend payout policy is the strategy a company adopts to distribute profits to its shareholders in the form of dividends. Governance around dividend payout ensures that the board, management, and shareholders act in compliance with statutory, regulatory, and fiduciary obligations while balancing growth and shareholder returns.
1. Legal Framework in India
Dividend governance is regulated under:
Companies Act, 2013
Section 123: Mandates declaration and payment of dividends out of profits.
Section 124: Unpaid or unclaimed dividends must be transferred to the Investor Education and Protection Fund (IEPF).
Section 134: Board’s report must disclose dividend proposals and rationale.
SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015
Requires listed companies to disclose dividend policies and ensure fair treatment of shareholders.
Accounting Standards (AS) / Ind AS
Dividend distribution requires proper accounting in accordance with profit recognition standards.
Governance Principles:
Board Oversight: The board must assess profits, reserves, and cash flow before approving dividends.
Equitable Treatment of Shareholders: Dividend policy should avoid favoritism toward certain shareholders.
Financial Prudence: Retain sufficient earnings for future growth while ensuring reasonable shareholder returns.
Disclosure: Transparent communication of the dividend rationale and methodology to shareholders.
2. Types of Dividend Policies
Stable Dividend Policy – Pays a consistent percentage of earnings.
Residual Dividend Policy – Pays dividends from residual profits after investment requirements.
Hybrid Policy – Combination of stable and residual policies.
Special Dividend – One-time payment due to exceptional profits or events.
3. Governance Mechanisms
Board Committees
Audit Committee: Validates distributable profits.
Finance Committee: Assesses liquidity and capital requirements.
Shareholder Approvals
Ordinary or special resolutions may be required for interim or final dividends.
Internal Controls
Proper bookkeeping to ensure dividends are paid only from free reserves.
Regulatory Compliance
Filing with ROC and disclosure in financial statements.
Risk Management
Avoid over-distribution that may jeopardize debt covenants or operational needs.
4. Key Case Laws on Dividend Governance in India
Bharat Aluminium Co. v. Kaiser Aluminium Technical Services, 2012
Board’s discretion in dividend payout must be exercised in good faith and in line with the company’s financial health.
Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd., 1965
Courts emphasized that dividends must be paid out of profits; illegal dividend payments are recoverable.
CIT v. Bombay Suburban Electric Supply Co. Ltd., 1965
Confirmed that capital cannot be distributed as dividend; only profits can be legally distributed.
A.P. State Financial Corporation v. Suri & Co., 1991
Directors can be held liable for unauthorized or excessive dividend declarations that affect creditors’ interests.
Standard Chartered Bank v. Madan Lal Jain, 1994
Courts ruled that dividend policies must comply with Articles of Association; any violation is ultra vires.
Sethia Steel Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT, 2005
Confirmed that companies must retain proper reserves and follow the dividend declaration procedures under the Companies Act.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. v. SEBI, 2006
SEBI highlighted the need for listed companies to adopt formal dividend distribution policies to prevent insider favoritism.
Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. SEBI, 2007
Reinforced transparency in dividend declaration, requiring advance intimation to shareholders and stock exchanges.
5. Best Practices in Dividend Governance
Draft a formal dividend policy approved by the Board.
Link dividends to sustainable earnings and future capital needs.
Ensure statutory compliance with Companies Act and SEBI regulations.
Disclose rationale, payout ratio, and historical dividends to shareholders.
Avoid dividends from borrowed funds unless explicitly allowed.
Implement internal audit checks to prevent overpayment and misappropriation.
6. Practical Implications
For shareholders: Guarantees predictability and fair treatment in dividend distribution.
For management: Provides a framework to balance growth and shareholder returns.
For regulators: Ensures transparency, compliance, and accountability in corporate finance.
RELATED Blog
comments