Corporate Remedies For Contract Breach.
Corporate Remedies for Breach of Contract
1. Meaning of Contract Breach in Corporate Context
A breach of contract occurs when one party to a legally enforceable agreement fails to perform its obligations without lawful excuse. In the corporate context, breaches commonly arise from:
Commercial supply and service agreements
Shareholders’ agreements
Joint venture and collaboration contracts
Financing and loan agreements
Employment and managerial contracts
The remedies available to corporations are governed primarily by the Indian Contract Act, 1872, Specific Relief Act, 1963, and supported by company law principles.
2. Classification of Breach of Contract
A. Actual Breach
Failure to perform on the due date
Defective or incomplete performance
B. Anticipatory Breach
Express refusal before performance date
Conduct making performance impossible
C. Fundamental (Material) Breach
Breach that goes to the root of the contract
3. Corporate Remedies for Contract Breach
A. Suit for Damages (Section 73, Contract Act)
Damages are the primary remedy for breach of contract.
Types of Damages
Ordinary (Compensatory) Damages – loss naturally arising
Special Damages – losses communicated at contract formation
Consequential Damages – indirect but foreseeable losses
Liquidated Damages – pre-estimated damages in contract
📌 Punitive damages are generally not awarded in contract law.
B. Suit for Specific Performance
Under the Specific Relief Act, 1963, courts may compel actual performance where:
Monetary compensation is inadequate
Contract involves unique goods or services
Common in:
Infrastructure contracts
Share transfer obligations
Long-term commercial arrangements
C. Injunctions (Preventive Relief)
Courts may restrain a party from:
Breaching negative covenants
Acting contrary to contractual obligations
Includes:
Temporary injunctions
Permanent injunctions
D. Rescission of Contract
The aggrieved corporation may:
Treat the contract as voidable
Claim compensation for losses
Applicable where breach is:
Fundamental
Induced by fraud or misrepresentation
E. Quantum Meruit
Allows recovery for:
Work done or services rendered
Partial performance where contract is discharged
Used when:
Contract becomes void
Performance is prevented by the other party
F. Restitution
Aims to:
Restore unjust enrichment
Return benefits received without legal basis
G. Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution
Most corporate contracts provide for:
Arbitration clauses
Institutional or ad hoc arbitration
Courts enforce such clauses under arbitration law principles.
4. Remedies in Special Corporate Contracts
A. Shareholders’ Agreements
Injunctions against share transfer
Specific performance of exit clauses
Damages for breach of veto or voting rights
B. Joint Venture Agreements
Termination
Injunction against misuse of IP
Enforcement of non-compete clauses
5. Leading Case Laws on Corporate Contract Remedies
1. Hadley v. Baxendale
The Court laid down the rule that damages must arise:
Naturally from the breach, or
Be within the contemplation of parties
📌 Foundational principle under Section 73.
2. Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Dass
The Supreme Court held that:
Liquidated damages are subject to reasonableness
Courts will award only actual proved loss
📌 Key authority on penalty clauses.
3. ONGC Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd.
The Supreme Court upheld enforcement of:
Liquidated damages clauses
Where loss is difficult to quantify
📌 Major corporate contracts precedent.
4. Kailash Nath Associates v. DDA
The Supreme Court ruled that:
Compensation cannot be awarded where no loss is proved
Even in liquidated damages clauses
📌 Refined approach to damages.
5. Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co.
The Supreme Court upheld:
Enforcement of negative covenants
Grant of injunctions in commercial contracts
📌 Leading case on injunctive relief.
6. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Amritsar Gas Service
The Supreme Court held that:
Specific performance is not available for determinable contracts
Only damages may be awarded
📌 Key limitation on specific performance.
7. Energy Watchdog v. CERC
The Supreme Court clarified:
Commercial hardship does not excuse breach
Force majeure clauses must be strictly construed
📌 Important for long-term commercial contracts.
6. Corporate Defences to Contract Breach Claims
Force majeure
Frustration of contract (Section 56)
Novation or alteration
Waiver or acquiescence
Limitation and laches
7. Corporate Governance Angle
Directors may incur liability where:
Breach results from negligent decision-making
Contract entered ultra vires company objects
Loss caused due to bad faith
Such breaches may also trigger:
Fiduciary breach proceedings
Derivative actions by shareholders
8. Conclusion
Corporate remedies for breach of contract in India reflect a balanced legal framework that prioritizes compensation over punishment, while allowing equitable and preventive relief where justice demands. Judicial precedents consistently emphasize commercial certainty, reasonable compensation, and respect for contractual intent, making these remedies central to corporate risk management and dispute resolution.
RELATED Blog
comments