Corporate Compliance For Related-Party Agreements
📌 1. Introduction
Related-party transactions (RPTs) are transactions between a company and its related parties, such as directors, KMPs, promoters, or entities in which they have significant influence.
Corporate compliance ensures that:
Transactions are fair, transparent, and at arm’s length
Conflicts of interest are disclosed and managed
SEBI and Companies Act requirements are strictly adhered to
Legal Basis:
Companies Act, 2013 – Sections 188 (RPT approval), 177 (Audit Committee), 134 (financial statements disclosures)
SEBI LODR Regulations, 2015 – Reg 23 (related party transactions for listed companies)
Secretarial Standards (SS‑1 & SS‑2) – Board and general meeting processes
Accounting Standards (AS‑18 / Ind AS 24) – Disclosure of related party transactions in financial statements
📌 2. Definition of Related Parties
Under Companies Act, 2013 Section 2(76) and LODR Reg 2(1)(zb):
Directors and their relatives
Key managerial personnel (KMP) and relatives
Promoters and entities controlled by them
Subsidiaries, joint ventures, and associates
Secretarial duty: Maintain register of related parties and update periodically.
📌 3. Key Compliance Requirements
🔹 1. Audit Committee Approval (Sec 177 / LODR 23)
All RPTs require prior approval of the Audit Committee
Audit committee must verify:
Transaction is arm’s length
Disclosure of conflict of interest
CS ensures Audit Committee resolutions are properly recorded
🔹 2. Board Approval (Sec 188)
Certain RPTs exceeding thresholds (financial or material) require Board approval
CS ensures proper documentation of:
Board notice and agenda
Conflict of interest declarations
Approval resolution and signing of agreements
🔹 3. Shareholder Approval (Sec 188 / LODR 23)
Listed companies must obtain shareholder approval for:
Material related-party transactions exceeding 10% of annual consolidated turnover
CS role:
Draft Explanatory Statement under Sec 102
Conduct EGM / AGM, ensure quorum, maintain minutes
🔹 4. Disclosure Requirements
Annual RPT disclosure in Form AOC‑2 for Companies Act
Listed companies must:
File material RPT disclosures with stock exchanges under LODR Reg 23
Include RPT summary in annual report and corporate governance report
CS Role: Ensure timely and accurate filings
🔹 5. Arm’s Length and Pricing Verification
Ensure RPTs are at arm’s length:
Use valuation reports if necessary
Ensure transfer pricing rules compliance for international transactions
🔹 6. Record-Keeping and Registers
Maintain:
Register of contracts/arrangements with related parties
Board and shareholder resolutions
Approvals and disclosure forms
Records must be kept for at least 8 years
🔹 7. Penalties for Non-Compliance
| Violation | Provision | Penalty / Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Approval without Audit Committee / Board | Sec 177 / 188 | Fine on company & officers: ₹25,000 – ₹5,00,000 |
| Non-disclosure in financial statements | Sec 134 | Penalty on company & officers; audit scrutiny |
| Material RPT without shareholder approval | Sec 188 / LODR 23 | SEBI action, fines, reputational risk |
| Misstatement of related-party interest | LODR / Companies Act | Civil / criminal liability, disgorgement |
| Non-filing Form AOC‑2 | Sec 134 / 188 | Fine on company and officers |
📌 4. Case Laws on Related-Party Agreements
1️⃣ Sahara India Real Estate Corp Ltd. vs SEBI
Issue: Non-disclosure of material RPTs with promoters and subsidiaries.
Holding: SEBI penalized directors; CS must ensure complete and timely disclosure of RPTs.
2️⃣ ICICI Bank vs SEBI
Issue: RPTs with directors not approved by Audit Committee.
Holding: Fine imposed; CS role emphasized in audit committee approvals.
3️⃣ Bhushan Steel Ltd. vs SEBI
Issue: RPTs with promoters and holding companies without shareholder approval.
Holding: Material RPTs require shareholder approval; CS ensures compliance and filings.
4️⃣ Reliance Industries Ltd. vs SEBI
Issue: Delay in disclosure of RPTs in financial statements and stock exchange filings.
Holding: CS responsible for timely filing and reporting under LODR Reg 23.
5️⃣ Jet Airways Ltd. vs SEBI
Issue: RPTs with group companies misrepresented in audit report.
Holding: CS and directors liable; need for accurate record-keeping and audit committee review.
6️⃣ Suzlon Energy Ltd. vs SEBI
Issue: Related-party loans and guarantees not disclosed to shareholders.
Holding: Directors and CS held accountable; required RPTs to be approved and disclosed.
📌 5. Practical Guidelines for Company Secretaries
Maintain an updated register of related parties and monitor transactions.
Ensure Audit Committee approves all RPTs, including arm’s length verification.
Obtain Board approval for transactions exceeding thresholds.
Identify material RPTs requiring shareholder approval and conduct EGM/AGM.
Ensure timely filing of Form AOC‑2 with ROC and LODR disclosures with stock exchanges.
Draft explanatory statements and maintain minutes for all approvals.
Monitor transfer pricing compliance for international RPTs.
Maintain all records, approvals, and disclosures for at least 8 years.
📌 6. Summary Table: CS Responsibilities for RPT Compliance
| Compliance Area | Regulation / Law | CS Responsibility |
|---|---|---|
| Identification of RPTs | Companies Act Sec 2(76) | Maintain register of related parties |
| Audit Committee Approval | Sec 177 | Ensure prior approval and arm’s length verification |
| Board Approval | Sec 188 | Draft agenda, obtain resolutions, document agreements |
| Shareholder Approval | Sec 188 / LODR 23 | Conduct EGM/AGM, file explanatory statements |
| Disclosure to ROC | Form AOC‑2 | File annual related-party transactions |
| Disclosure to Stock Exchanges | LODR Reg 23 | Timely filings of material RPTs |
| Annual Report / Governance Report | Sec 134 / LODR 34 | Include RPT details in financials and reports |
| Record-Keeping | Companies Act Sec 88, 189 | Maintain registers, resolutions, approvals |

comments