CAN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE BE GRANTED LEGAL PERSONALITY?

CAN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE BE GRANTED LEGAL PERSONALITY?

A Jurisprudential Analysis of Rights, Duties and Legal Accountability

1. Introduction

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become an important part of modern life. From virtual assistants and online banking to medical diagnosis and automated decision-making, AI systems are increasingly performing tasks that were once handled exclusively by human beings. Some advanced systems can even analyze information, make recommendations and perform transactions with limited human involvement.

Although these developments offer several benefits, they also raise an important legal question: What happens when an AI system causes harm, makes a discriminatory decision or becomes involved in a contractual dispute? Who should be held responsible — the developer, the user, the company operating the system or the AI itself?

This question introduces an interesting debate in jurisprudence: Can Artificial Intelligence be recognized as a legal person with independent rights and duties?

Traditionally, legal personality has been associated with human beings and certain artificial entities, such as corporations. However, the increasing independence of AI systems challenges the traditional understanding of legal personality. This article examines the concept through classical jurisprudential theories, Indian legal principles and international developments to understand whether AI should receive independent legal recognition.

2. Understanding Legal Personality in Jurisprudence

Before discussing whether AI can become a legal person, it is important to understand what legal personality means.

Legal personality refers to the status recognized by law that allows an entity to possess rights, bear duties and participate in legal relationships. A legal person may own property, enter into contracts, sue others and be sued.

Salmond's Theory of Legal Personality

According to jurist John Salmond, a person is any being whom the law regards as capable of rights and duties. This definition shows that legal personality is not necessarily limited to biological human beings. An entity may receive legal recognition if the law grants it certain rights and obligations.

Kelsen's Pure Theory of Law

Hans Kelsen viewed legal personality as a legal construction rather than simply a biological fact. According to his approach, a person is a point to which legal rights and duties are attributed by the legal system.

This understanding is important because it suggests that legal personality can be created by law. However, it does not automatically mean that every entity capable of performing complex activities should receive independent legal status.

Natural Persons and Juristic Persons

Legal persons are generally understood through two broad categories:

Natural Persons: Human beings who are recognized by law as having legal rights and duties.

Juristic Persons: Entities recognized by law as having a separate legal identity, such as companies and certain statutory or religious institutions.

The recognition of juristic persons demonstrates that legal personality is not restricted to human beings. The question is whether this principle can also be extended to artificial intelligence.

3. The Corporate Analogy: Can AI Be Compared to a Company?

One of the strongest arguments supporting AI legal personality comes from the recognition of corporations as separate legal persons.

A company does not have a physical body or human consciousness. Yet, once incorporated under the law, it receives an independent legal identity. It can own property, enter into contracts, sue and be sued.

The Principle in Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd. (1897)

In Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd., [1897] AC 22, the House of Lords recognized that a properly incorporated company has a legal identity separate from its shareholders and directors.

The decision established the principle of separate corporate personality. It demonstrated that the law can recognise an artificial entity as a legal person even though it is not a human being.

Supporters of AI legal personality use this principle to argue that advanced AI systems could also receive limited legal recognition. For example, an autonomous AI system involved in commercial transactions could theoretically be assigned a separate asset fund or insurance arrangement to meet certain financial obligations.

However, there is an important difference. A company operates through human directors, employees and shareholders who can be held accountable. An AI system does not have the same organizational structure or human decision-making capacity.

Therefore, the corporate analogy provides an argument for discussion, but it does not establish that AI should automatically receive legal personality.

4. Agency, Civil Liability and the Problem of Accountability

At present, AI systems are generally treated as technological tools rather than independent legal persons. When an AI system causes harm, responsibility is usually examined through existing legal principles.

Product Liability

If an AI-enabled product causes harm because of a defect in its design, development or functioning, questions may arise regarding the responsibility of its manufacturer, developer or supplier.

For example, if an autonomous vehicle causes an accident because of a software defect, the law may examine whether the manufacturer or another responsible party failed to meet the required standard of care.

Vicarious Liability and Human Responsibility

Where an organization uses AI as part of its business operations, the conduct of the people and entities responsible for deploying and supervising the system may become relevant.

The question is whether the organization or individual acted negligently, failed to exercise reasonable care or violated an existing legal obligation.

The Black Box Problem

One of the major difficulties with modern AI is the so-called black box problem. Certain AI systems use complex processes to generate decisions, making it difficult to understand exactly how a particular result was produced.

Consider an AI-based medical diagnostic system that incorrectly identifies a medical condition. The error may result from inaccurate training data, a software defect or an unexpected system response.

Determining who is responsible can become complicated when several parties are involved.

However, the difficulty of identifying responsibility does not necessarily mean that AI itself should become a legal person. It may instead require clearer rules regarding transparency, supervision, liability and compensation.

5. Arguments Supporting Legal Personality for AI

Some legal scholars and technology experts believe that granting limited legal personality to advanced AI systems could help address certain legal and commercial challenges.

Economic Efficiency and Compensation

Advanced AI systems are increasingly involved in financial transactions, automated services and business activities. Supporters argue that a separate legal status could allow certain AI systems to be connected to dedicated financial resources or mandatory insurance arrangements.

Such arrangements could help compensate individuals who suffer losses because of an AI-related incident.

Recognition of Autonomous Activities

Certain AI systems can independently execute transactions, manage digital operations and interact with other systems.

Supporters believe that the law should consider whether advanced AI systems performing such activities require a specific legal framework to clarify their responsibilities.

Development of Technology

Some argue that recognizing limited legal status for AI could encourage innovation by providing greater certainty in commercial transactions involving autonomous systems.

However, these arguments depend on whether legal personality would genuinely improve accountability and compensation or simply create another layer of legal complexity.

6. Arguments Against Legal Personality for AI

Despite the arguments supporting recognition, several serious concerns arise when considering AI as an independent legal person.

Absence of Consciousness and Moral Responsibility

Human beings can understand social rules, make moral choices and accept responsibility for their actions. Present-day AI systems process information and generate outputs based on their design, training and computational processes.

They do not possess human consciousness or moral understanding.

This creates difficulty when applying legal concepts that depend on intention, knowledge or deliberate wrongdoing.

The Problem of Punishment

Legal personality is generally associated with both rights and obligations. If AI receives independent legal status, an important question follows: How should the law punish it when it violates legal obligations?

A human being can be imprisoned or fined. A company can face financial penalties or dissolution. But applying similar punishments to software is difficult.

An AI system can potentially be copied, modified or transferred to another server. Simply deleting one version may not permanently prevent the system from operating elsewhere.

Therefore, the effectiveness of legal sanctions against AI remains uncertain.

Risk of Avoiding Human Responsibility

Another major concern is that developers, companies or users might attempt to escape responsibility by blaming an AI system for harmful decisions.

If AI is treated as an independent legal person, organizations could potentially use that status to distance themselves from the consequences of their own decisions.

The law must ensure that technological development does not become an excuse for avoiding accountability.

7. Criminal Liability: Can AI Be Punished for a Crime?

The question of criminal liability makes the debate even more complicated.

Traditional criminal law generally examines two important elements:

Actus Reus: The guilty act or prohibited conduct.

Mens Rea: The guilty mind or required mental element.

An AI system may perform an action that results in serious harm. For example, an automated system could make a decision that contributes to financial fraud or a dangerous accident.

However, performing an action does not automatically mean that the system possesses criminal intention.

AI does not experience guilt, remorse or moral awareness in the human sense. Therefore, applying traditional criminal punishment to AI raises serious difficulties.

The main question is not simply whether AI can perform an act that causes harm, but whether it can possess the mental element required for a particular criminal offence.

At present, criminal responsibility must be examined through the conduct and applicable legal duties of the human beings and organizations involved.

Theories of punishment also raise concerns:

Retribution: AI cannot experience moral blame or remorse.

Deterrence: The threat of punishment may not influence an AI system in the same way it influences human behavior.

Rehabilitation: Software cannot undergo moral reform in the manner of a human offender.

Incapacitation: A system may be disabled or restricted, but this is primarily a safety measure rather than conventional punishment.

These difficulties demonstrate why independent criminal personality for AI remains highly controversial.

8. International Perspective: How Is the World Approaching AI?

The question of AI legal personality has also received attention at the international level.

European Parliament's 2017 Electronic Personhood Proposal

In its resolution of 16 February 2017 on Civil Law Rules on Robotics, the European Parliament asked the European Commission to examine several possible legal solutions for addressing damage caused by advanced robots.

One of the proposals was to consider creating a specific legal status for certain sophisticated autonomous robots, sometimes described as electronic persons.

However, this was a recommendation for further consideration, not a law granting legal personality to AI. The proposal attracted considerable criticism and remains an important part of the debate on electronic personhood.

The European Union Artificial Intelligence Act

The European Union later adopted the Artificial Intelligence Act, Regulation (EU) 2024/1689.

Instead of granting AI independent legal personality, the Act establishes a risk-based regulatory framework. It places obligations on relevant human and organizational stakeholders, including providers and deployers of AI systems.

For high-risk AI systems, the framework includes requirements relating to risk management, documentation, transparency, human oversight and monitoring.

This approach reflects an important legal principle: AI can be regulated without treating it as an independent legal person.

The Position in India

India does not currently have a separate legal status recognizing artificial intelligence as an independent legal person.

AI-related activities are addressed through existing legal frameworks depending on the nature of the issue. These may include the Information Technology Act, 2000, the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the Copyright Act, 1957 and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, where their respective provisions apply.

For example, if an AI-enabled service causes harm to a consumer, the responsibility of the relevant company or service provider may be examined under applicable consumer protection principles.

Similarly, misuse of personal data through AI systems may raise questions under data protection law.

India's present approach therefore focuses on regulating the use of technology and identifying responsible parties rather than granting AI independent legal personality.

9. Critical Analysis: Should AI Receive Legal Personality?

The debate over AI legal personality requires a balance between technological development and legal accountability.

On one hand, the recognition of corporations and other artificial entities shows that legal personality is not limited to biological human beings. The law has the flexibility to recognise different entities when there is a practical legal need.

On the other hand, AI systems are fundamentally different from companies. A company has a legally recognized structure, identifiable representatives and assets. An AI system, by itself, does not have the same independent organizational or financial foundation.

Granting AI legal personality without clearly defining its rights, duties, assets and responsibilities could create confusion rather than solve existing legal problems.

A more practical approach would be to strengthen the laws governing AI developers, manufacturers, service providers and users. There should also be clear standards for human supervision, transparency, data protection and compensation when AI systems cause harm.

Legal personality should not be granted merely because technology has become advanced. It should be considered only if such recognition serves a genuine legal purpose and does not weaken human accountability.

10. Conclusion

Can Artificial Intelligence be granted legal personality? The answer is not as simple as saying that AI is only a machine or that it should automatically receive the same status as a company.

Classical jurisprudence demonstrates that legal personality is a status created and recognized by law. The recognition of corporations proves that biological existence is not an absolute requirement for becoming a legal person.

However, granting AI independent legal personality raises serious questions concerning responsibility, intention, punishment and enforcement. Present-day AI systems do not possess human consciousness or moral understanding, and their actions can often be traced to the people and organizations that develop, deploy and use them.

Therefore, instead of immediately recognizing AI as an independent legal person, the law should focus on establishing effective rules for its development and use. Clear liability standards, human supervision, transparency and proper compensation mechanisms are essential.

Ultimately, the challenge for modern jurisprudence is not simply to decide whether AI can become a legal person, but to ensure that technological progress never becomes a reason for human beings to escape legal responsibility.

REFERENCES AND BIBLIOGRAPHY

A. Books and Jurisprudential Works

  • John William Salmond, Jurisprudence (12th ed., Sweet & Maxwell).
  • Hans Kelsen, Pure Theory of Law (Max Knight trans., University of California Press, 1967).
  • Visa A. J. Kurki, Legal Personhood (Cambridge University Press, 2023).

B. Cases

  • Salomon v. A. Salomon & Co. Ltd., [1897] AC 22 (HL).

C. Research Articles and Academic Publications

  • Joanna J. Bryson, Mihailis E. Diamantis & Thomas D. Grant, “Of, for, and by the People: The Legal Lacuna of Synthetic Persons,” 25 Artificial Intelligence and Law 273–291 (2017).
  • Thomas Buocz & Iris Eisenberger, “Demystifying Legal Personhood for Non-Human Entities: A Kelsenian Approach,” 43 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 32–53 (2023).
  • Visa A. J. Kurki, Legal Personhood, Cambridge University Press (2023).

D. Legislation and International Legal Materials

  • Information Technology Act, 2000 (India).
  • Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (India).
  • Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (India).
  • Copyright Act, 1957 (India).
  • Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (India).
  • Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 – Artificial Intelligence Act.
  • European Parliament Resolution of 16 February 2017 on Civil Law Rules on Robotics (2015/2103(INL)).

E. Online Research Resources

  • Cambridge University Press – Legal Personhood.
  • Oxford Academic – Demystifying Legal Personhood for Non-Human Entities.
  • European Union – Artificial Intelligence Act.
  • European Parliament – Resolution on Civil Law Rules on Robotics.
  • INFLIBNET – Advanced Jurisprudence: The Concept of Legal Personality.


AUTHOR
Divya.H 
A Student from ABBS School of Law 

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT