Biotechnology Surrogacy Law In Russia.

1. Introduction

Surrogacy law in Russia is an important branch of biotechnology law, reproductive medicine law, family law, medical ethics and human-rights regulation. It governs the legal arrangement under which a woman (the surrogate mother) carries and gives birth to a child for intended parents who cannot carry a pregnancy themselves for medical reasons.

Russia has historically been one of the countries permitting both commercial and altruistic surrogacy. However, the legal framework underwent a significant transformation through Federal Law No. 538-FZ of 19 December 2022, which restricted access to surrogacy for foreign nationals and introduced stricter eligibility requirements.

Russian surrogacy law addresses several important questions:

Who is legally eligible to use surrogacy?

Who can become a surrogate mother?

Who has parental rights over a child born through surrogacy?

Can a surrogate mother refuse to transfer the child?

What happens when intended parents and surrogate mothers disagree?

How are embryos and genetic materials regulated?

What happens when a child is born with disabilities?

What legal protections are available to the child?

The principal legal framework is contained in the Russian Family Code, Federal Law No. 323-FZ of 21 November 2011 and Federal Law No. 143-FZ of 15 November 1997.

2. Constitutional and legislative framework

Several legal provisions govern surrogacy in Russia.

LegislationLegal significance
Constitution of the Russian FederationProtection of family, motherhood, childhood and human dignity
Family Code, Article 51Registration of intended parents
Family Code, Article 52Challenges to parentage
Federal Law No. 323-FZ, Article 55Regulation of assisted reproductive technologies and surrogacy
Federal Law No. 143-FZ, Article 16Registration of births
Federal Law No. 538-FZ of 2022Restrictions concerning foreign intended parents
Ministry of Health Order No. 803n of 2020Medical procedures involving assisted reproductive technologies

These laws collectively regulate the medical, contractual and family-law dimensions of surrogacy.

3. Article 55 of Federal Law No. 323-FZ: Surrogacy regulation

Article 55 of Federal Law No. 323-FZ, On the Fundamentals of Health Protection of Citizens in the Russian Federation, is the principal statutory provision governing surrogacy.

It recognises surrogacy as an assisted reproductive technology.

Under Article 55(9), surrogacy involves carrying and delivering a child under an agreement between a surrogate mother and intended parents.

The arrangement requires medical grounds demonstrating that pregnancy and childbirth are impossible for the intended parents.

The legislation recognises:

A married couple consisting of a genetic mother and genetic father.

A single woman who uses her own genetic material and cannot carry a pregnancy for medical reasons.

The law therefore establishes eligibility based on medical necessity, marital status and genetic parentage.

Important restriction: Unmarried couples cannot use surrogacy under the amended Article 55(3).

Consultant Plus+1

4. Eligibility requirements for surrogate mothers

Article 55(10) establishes specific conditions for becoming a surrogate mother.

A surrogate mother must:

Be between 20 and 35 years of age.

Possess Russian citizenship.

Have at least one healthy biological child of her own.

Obtain a medical certificate confirming satisfactory health.

Provide written informed voluntary consent to medical intervention.

Obtain her husband's written consent if she is married.

Not simultaneously act as the egg donor.

These requirements seek to protect the health and autonomy of surrogate mothers and ensure that the reproductive arrangement is medically supervised.

The prohibition on acting simultaneously as an egg donor establishes a gestational surrogacy model.

In this model, the surrogate carries an embryo but does not provide the egg used to create it.

Consultant Plus+1

5. Commercial and altruistic surrogacy

Russia permits both commercial and altruistic surrogacy.

Commercial surrogacy

Commercial surrogacy involves financial compensation to the surrogate mother.

Compensation may cover:

Pregnancy-related expenses.

Medical treatment.

Nutrition and accommodation.

Pregnancy-related loss of income.

Contractually agreed compensation for carrying and delivering the child.

Altruistic surrogacy

Altruistic surrogacy involves carrying a pregnancy without commercial remuneration, although reasonable pregnancy-related expenses may be reimbursed.

Russian legislation recognises surrogacy under Article 55(9), but it does not provide a comprehensive statutory model contract governing every contractual issue.

Consequently, the parties must pay particular attention to the Civil Code provisions governing contractual obligations, medical consent and family relationships.

A surrogacy agreement cannot override mandatory rules concerning parental status, medical consent or the rights of the child.

6. Federal Law No. 538-FZ of 2022: Restrictions on foreign nationals

Major legislative development

Federal Law No. 538-FZ, dated 19 December 2022, significantly changed Russian surrogacy law.

Before this legislation, Russia was a major destination for international surrogacy arrangements.

The 2022 amendments restricted access for foreign nationals and stateless persons.

Under the amended framework:

Intended parents must satisfy the Russian citizenship requirements.

Married intended parents may qualify where one or both spouses are Russian citizens at the relevant statutory times.

A single intended mother must be a Russian citizen.

The surrogate mother must also possess Russian citizenship.

A child born in Russia through surrogacy acquires Russian citizenship by birth under the applicable statutory provisions.

The legislation also introduced transitional provisions for certain arrangements already underway when the law entered into force.

Legal significance: Russia moved from a relatively internationally accessible surrogacy system towards a nationality-restricted domestic framework.

ГАРАНТ+2

7. Parental rights under Article 51 of the Russian Family Code

Article 51(4) of the Family Code regulates the registration of children born through surrogacy.

The provision establishes that intended parents who have given written consent to embryo implantation into another woman may be registered as the child's parents only with the consent of the woman who gave birth.

This creates an important legal distinction between:

Genetic parenthood.

Gestational motherhood.

Legally registered parenthood.

The intended parents may provide the genetic material, but the surrogate mother's consent is required for their registration as parents.

This requirement creates a potential legal conflict where the surrogate mother changes her mind after childbirth.

However, the refusal of consent does not necessarily end the intended parents' legal claim.

The courts can examine the circumstances and determine parentage in accordance with the child's best interests.

Supreme Court of the Russian Federation+1

8. Article 52: Disputes concerning parentage

Article 52 of the Family Code regulates the challenge of maternity and paternity.

Under Article 52(3), after the intended parents and surrogate mother have been registered as the child's parents, they generally cannot challenge parentage merely by relying on the fact that the child was born through embryo implantation into another woman.

This provision promotes legal certainty and prevents indefinite disputes over parental identity.

It also protects children from prolonged uncertainty concerning their legal family relationships.

However, questions involving fraud, abuse of rights, defects in consent or unlawful registration may require judicial examination.

9. Important Russian case laws on surrogacy

Russian judicial decisions have played a significant role in interpreting the relationship between genetic parenthood, gestational motherhood and the welfare of the child.

Case 1. Constitutional Court of Russia — Determination No. 880-O of 15 May 2012

Important constitutional decision

Facts

A married couple entered into a surrogacy agreement with a woman in February 2010.

The intended parents provided the genetic material, and an embryo was implanted into the surrogate mother.

However, the surrogate mother subsequently withdrew her participation and refused to consent to registration of the intended parents as the child's parents.

The child was registered in the name of the surrogate mother.

The genetic parents challenged the refusal before the courts.

Legal issue

Whether Article 51(4) of the Family Code and Article 16(5) of the Birth Registration Law violated the constitutional rights of genetic parents by requiring the surrogate mother's consent.

Decision

The Constitutional Court refused to accept the constitutional complaint for consideration.

It upheld the existing statutory framework requiring the surrogate mother's consent for registration of the intended parents.

Legal principles

The woman who gives birth has an important legally recognised position.

Genetic parenthood does not automatically guarantee registration as a parent.

The statutory consent requirement forms part of the Russian system of reproductive regulation.

Significance

This decision established an important foundation for understanding the legal relationship between genetic parenthood and gestational motherhood in Russia.

ГАРАНТ

Case 2. Supreme Court of Russia — Plenum Resolution No. 16 of 16 May 2017

Leading judicial authority

Facts and legal background

The Supreme Court considered how courts should resolve disputes concerning children born through assisted reproductive technologies, including surrogacy.

The central issue was the legal consequence of a surrogate mother's refusal to consent to registration of intended parents.

Legal issue

Whether the surrogate mother's refusal automatically prevents genetic parents from obtaining legal recognition as the child's parents.

Decision and interpretation

Paragraph 31 of Resolution No. 16 provides that refusal by the surrogate mother does not constitute an absolute ground for rejecting the intended parents' claim.

Courts should investigate:

Whether a valid surrogacy agreement existed.

What obligations were included in the agreement.

Whether the claimants are the genetic parents.

Why the surrogate mother refused consent.

What outcome protects the child's best interests.

Legal principles

The Supreme Court established that:

The child's welfare must be central to judicial decision-making.

The existence of a surrogacy agreement is relevant evidence.

Genetic parentage must be examined.

The surrogate mother's refusal is not automatically decisive.

Courts must consider Article 3 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.

Significance

This is one of the most important judicial authorities governing Russian surrogacy disputes.

It provides a mechanism for resolving conflicts between contractual expectations, biological relationships and the welfare of the child.

Supreme Court of the Russian Federation+1

Case 3. Constitutional Court of Russia — Determination No. 2318-O of 27 September 2018

Facts

The applicants challenged provisions of the Family Code and legislation governing birth registration.

The dispute concerned the legal status of intended parents and the requirement for the surrogate mother's consent.

Legal issue

Whether the statutory requirement for the surrogate mother's consent was compatible with constitutional protections of family, motherhood and childhood.

Decision

The Constitutional Court declined to accept the complaint for consideration.

It explained that the statutory provisions must be interpreted together with the Supreme Court's 2017 Resolution No. 16.

Accordingly, if the surrogate mother refuses consent, courts may still examine a claim by intended parents by considering the agreement, genetic parentage, reasons for refusal and the child's best interests.

Legal principles

Surrogate motherhood has an independent legal significance.

Genetic parenthood is relevant to determining legal parentage.

The child's welfare remains central.

Judicial examination must consider the circumstances of each dispute.

Significance

The decision reinforces the importance of interpreting the statutory consent requirement together with the Supreme Court's guidance.

ГАРАНТ

Case 4. Constitutional Court of Russia — Determination No. 1222-O of 13 May 2025

Recent judicial development

Legal background

This decision concerns the statutory requirements for using surrogacy by married intended parents.

The dispute involved the requirement that the reproductive material used to create the embryo must satisfy the statutory genetic-parentage conditions.

Legal issue

Whether the requirement concerning the use of reproductive cells of both spouses was constitutionally permissible.

Decision

The Constitutional Court declined to accept the complaint for consideration.

It explained that the statutory framework, interpreted together with the applicable rules, requires the use of reproductive cells from both spouses for the relevant surrogacy arrangement.

The Court considered that this requirement fell within the legislative authority of the federal legislature and served to balance constitutionally protected values and private and public interests.

Significance

This decision is important because it clarifies the relationship between genetic parentage and eligibility for surrogacy under the amended Russian framework.

It should be read alongside Article 55(9) of Federal Law No. 323-FZ.

ksrf.ru

10. International case law relevant to Russian surrogacy

Although the following decisions are not judgments of Russian courts, they are useful for understanding international disputes arising from Russian surrogacy arrangements.

A. Paradiso and Campanelli v. Italy (2017)

European Court of Human Rights — Grand Chamber

Facts

An Italian couple entered into a surrogacy arrangement in Russia.

A child was born through the arrangement, and the intended parents returned to Italy.

Italian authorities subsequently questioned the legal status of the child and the relationship between the intended parents and the child.

Legal issue

Whether removing the child from the intended parents violated their right to respect for private and family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Decision

The Grand Chamber found no violation of Article 8 in the circumstances of the case.

The Court considered, among other factors, the absence of a biological relationship between the intended parents and the child and the relatively short period during which family life had developed.

Significance

The case illustrates the difficulty of recognising parent-child relationships created through international surrogacy.

It also demonstrates that a surrogacy arrangement lawful in the country where it takes place does not automatically guarantee recognition in another country.

HUDOC

B. Re C (A Child) [2013] EWHC 2413 (Fam)

High Court of England and Wales

Facts

A child was born in Moscow through a Russian surrogacy arrangement involving intended parents from the United Kingdom.

The intended parents subsequently sought legal recognition in England.

Legal issue

Whether the intended parents could obtain a parental order under the applicable British legislation.

Significance

The proceedings demonstrate how differences between Russian parentage law and foreign family-law systems can create complex questions involving citizenship, parental responsibility and recognition of foreign birth documents.

BAILII

11. Legal regulation of surrogacy agreements

A surrogacy agreement is a central component of the reproductive arrangement.

It should clearly establish the parties' obligations.

Important contractual matters include:

Contractual issueLegal significance
Medical proceduresDefines the agreed reproductive treatment
Informed consentProtects reproductive autonomy
Medical expensesEstablishes financial responsibilities
Pregnancy monitoringRegulates medical supervision
CompensationEstablishes financial arrangements
Birth registrationAddresses parental registration
ConfidentialityProtects personal and medical information
Dispute resolutionEstablishes procedures for disagreements
Medical complicationsAllocates contractual responsibilities within mandatory law

However, the contract cannot remove the surrogate mother's statutory rights or guarantee that intended parents will automatically acquire legal parenthood.

The agreement must also respect the mandatory requirements of Russian medical and family legislation.

12. Protection of the child born through surrogacy

Child protection is one of the most significant dimensions of Russian biotechnology law.

Several legal problems may arise.

A. Refusal to accept the child

Intended parents may disagree about accepting a child because of congenital abnormalities or unexpected medical complications.

Russian law does not make a child's legal status dependent on whether the child satisfies the intended parents' preferences.

B. Surrogate mother refuses consent

The surrogate mother may refuse to consent to registration of the intended parents.

In such circumstances, judicial intervention may be necessary under the principles established in Supreme Court Resolution No. 16 of 2017.

C. Citizenship and identity

The citizenship provisions introduced through Federal Law No. 538-FZ are particularly important for children born through surrogacy in Russia.

D. Financial and maintenance obligations

Once legal parentage is established, ordinary family-law rules concerning parental responsibilities, maintenance and child protection become relevant.

E. Privacy and genetic information

Surrogacy may involve sensitive information relating to genetic material, reproductive health, medical records and family identity.

The processing of such information must comply with applicable Russian privacy and personal-data legislation.

13. Biotechnology, embryo protection and medical ethics

Russian surrogacy law also raises important biotechnology-related questions.

A. Embryo creation and implantation

Embryos are created through assisted reproductive technologies and transferred to the surrogate mother under the applicable medical framework.

Medical organisations must comply with the relevant licensing and medical standards.

B. Genetic material

The law distinguishes between genetic contributors and the woman carrying the pregnancy.

The surrogate mother cannot simultaneously be the egg donor under Article 55(10).

C. Informed consent

Medical consent must be voluntary and informed.

A surrogacy contract cannot justify medical intervention without the required consent.

D. Medical confidentiality

Reproductive health information must be protected under applicable confidentiality and personal-data requirements.

E. Medical negligence

Clinics may face legal consequences where negligent treatment, defective medical procedures or violations of medical regulations cause harm.

These matters may involve civil liability, professional responsibility and administrative regulation.

14. Major legal challenges in Russian surrogacy law

Despite the statutory framework, several legal challenges remain.

Legal challengeMain concern
Surrogate mother's refusalConflict over parental registration
Contractual uncertaintyIncomplete statutory regulation of agreements
Genetic parentageDifference between biological and legal parenthood
Foreign recognitionConflicting national family-law systems
CitizenshipNationality and identity of the child
Medical negligenceLiability of fertility clinics
Embryo disputesControl and use of reproductive material
Child abandonmentProtection of children when intended parents refuse care
PrivacyConfidentiality of genetic and reproductive information
Constitutional rightsBalancing reproductive autonomy and child welfare

15. Critical legal analysis

Russian surrogacy law reflects an attempt to balance three major legal interests.

First: reproductive autonomy.

Intended parents have an interest in accessing reproductive technologies where pregnancy is medically impossible.

Second: protection of surrogate mothers.

The law recognises the surrogate mother's consent and her legal position as the woman who gives birth.

Third: protection of children.

Children must receive legal recognition, family protection and appropriate maintenance regardless of disputes between adults.

The principal difficulty is that these interests may conflict.

For example, intended parents may rely on their genetic relationship and contractual agreement, while the surrogate mother may refuse consent to their registration.

The Supreme Court's 2017 Resolution No. 16 provides an important judicial mechanism for addressing this conflict by requiring courts to investigate the agreement, genetic parentage and the child's best interests.

The 2022 legislative amendments introduce another dimension: national citizenship and restrictions on international access.

Thus, Russian surrogacy law is no longer simply a question of reproductive medicine. It is also a question of citizenship, family identity, constitutional rights and international private law.

16. Conclusion

Biotechnology surrogacy law in Russia is governed principally by Article 55 of Federal Law No. 323-FZ, Articles 51 and 52 of the Family Code and Article 16 of Federal Law No. 143-FZ.

The 2022 amendments introduced significant restrictions concerning foreign intended parents and established additional eligibility requirements for surrogate mothers.

Russian judicial decisions, particularly Constitutional Court Determination No. 880-O (2012), Supreme Court Resolution No. 16 (2017), Constitutional Court Determination No. 2318-O (2018) and Determination No. 1222-O (2025), have clarified important questions concerning parental registration, genetic relationships and reproductive eligibility.

The central legal principle is that surrogacy disputes cannot be resolved exclusively through contractual provisions or genetic evidence. Courts must also consider the legal position of the woman who gives birth and, above all, the interests and protection of the child.

17. Important legal authorities and research references

For academic and legal research, the following primary sources are particularly useful:

Constitution of the Russian Federation.

Family Code of the Russian Federation, Articles 51 and 52.

Federal Law No. 323-FZ of 21 November 2011, Article 55.

Federal Law No. 143-FZ of 15 November 1997, Article 16.

Federal Law No. 538-FZ of 19 December 2022.

Supreme Court Plenum Resolution No. 16 of 16 May 2017.

Constitutional Court Determination No. 880-O of 15 May 2012.

Constitutional Court Determination No. 2318-O of 27 September 2018.

Constitutional Court Determination No. 1222-O of 13 May 2025.

Paradiso and Campanelli v. Italy (2017), European Court of Human Rights.

Re C (A Child) [2013] EWHC 2413 (Fam).

Useful primary-source websites:

Supreme Court of the Russian Federation

Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation

ConsultantPlus – Russian legislation

European Court of Human Rights – HUDOC

Academic note: This is a research overview, not an individual legal opinion. The precise application of the 2022 amendments and later judicial interpretations should be checked against the consolidated Russian legislation applicable on the relevant date.

I can also prepare Biotechnology Surrogacy Law in Russia: 20 Landmark Case Laws with Facts, Legal Issues, Judgments and Legal Principles as a separate case-law research chapter.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT