Mode of determining the existence of a partnership
The mode of determining the existence of a partnership generally involves examining the relationship and conduct of the parties involved to see if they fulfill the legal criteria of a partnership under applicable law (like the Partnership Act in many jurisdictions).
Key Points to Determine if a Partnership Exists:
1. Definition of Partnership (General)
A partnership is typically defined as:
"The relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all."
This means a partnership exists if:
There is an agreement (express or implied) between two or more persons,
To carry on a business,
In common,
With the intention to share profits.
2. Mode of Determination
a. Express Agreement
A written or oral agreement explicitly stating that the parties are partners.
Often the easiest way to establish a partnership.
b. Implied Agreement or Conduct
Even without a formal agreement, a partnership can be inferred from the conduct of the parties.
Examples of conduct indicating partnership:
Sharing of profits and losses.
Joint ownership of business assets.
Joint decision-making.
Acting on behalf of each other.
Holding themselves out as partners to third parties.
c. Sharing of Profits
Sharing of profits is a key indicator of partnership.
However, mere sharing of profits is not conclusive proof (e.g., payment of debt or wages can involve sharing profits but not necessarily mean partnership).
The sharing of losses also supports the existence of a partnership.
d. Business Activity
The parties must be carrying on a business, which includes trade, profession, or occupation.
Social or charitable activities typically do not constitute a business.
e. Intention to Form a Partnership
The parties must intend to form a partnership.
Mere co-ownership or joint investment does not automatically create a partnership.
3. Evidence Considered
Written agreements or contracts.
Conduct and behavior of parties.
Financial arrangements, including profit and loss sharing.
Representations made to third parties.
Business operations and control.
Summary Table:
| Element | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Agreement | Express or implied intention to be partners |
| Business | Continuous commercial activity |
| Sharing of Profits | Sharing profits from the business |
| Control and Management | Acting on behalf of one another |
| Representation | Holding out as partners to third parties |
Important:
If uncertain, courts look at substance over form, meaning they consider the actual relationship and dealings rather than just labels.
In some jurisdictions, registration or other formalities might be required, but the partnership may still be deemed to exist based on conduct.
Do write to us if you need any further assistance.
RELATED Blog
0 comments