Dispute Over Freight And Demurrage Claims
1. Meaning and Legal Nature
(a) Freight
Freight is the remuneration payable to the carrier for transporting goods. It may be:
- Advance Freight – payable before shipment
- Freight Earned – payable upon delivery
- Dead Freight – compensation for unused cargo space
Freight is governed by contract terms (charterparty or bill of lading) and principles under laws such as the Indian Contract Act.
(b) Demurrage
Demurrage is liquidated damages payable for delay beyond the agreed laytime for loading or unloading cargo.
Key features:
- It is pre-agreed compensation, not a penalty
- Payable regardless of fault (strict liability in most cases)
- Often calculated per day of delay
2. Common Causes of Disputes
(i) Laytime Calculation Issues
- Disputes over when laytime starts and stops
- Interpretation of terms like “weather working days”
(ii) Delay and Responsibility
- Whether delay is caused by charterer, shipowner, or third party
- Port congestion or customs delays
(iii) Exceptions Clauses
- Force majeure, strikes, or bad weather
- Whether such events suspend demurrage
(iv) Freight Payment Disputes
- Non-payment or partial payment
- Disagreement over freight earned vs. payable
(v) Dead Freight Claims
- Failure to supply agreed cargo quantity
3. Legal Principles Governing Freight and Demurrage
(a) Freight is Earned Upon Delivery (General Rule)
Freight becomes payable only after successful delivery unless otherwise agreed.
(b) Demurrage as Liquidated Damages
Once laytime is exceeded, demurrage applies automatically without proof of actual loss.
(c) Once on Demurrage, Always on Demurrage
Exceptions typically do not apply once demurrage begins unless expressly stated.
(d) Burden of Proof
- Shipowner must prove delay
- Charterer must prove exceptions
4. Important Case Laws
1. Aktieselskabet Reidar v Arcos Ltd
- Established the principle: “Once on demurrage, always on demurrage.”
- Exceptions do not interrupt demurrage unless explicitly provided.
2. The Spalmatori
- Clarified calculation of laytime and commencement of demurrage.
- Reinforced strict interpretation of charterparty clauses.
3. The Bonde
- Held that demurrage is the exclusive remedy for delay, unless otherwise stated.
- Owners cannot claim additional damages beyond demurrage.
4. The Johanna Oldendorff
- Defined “arrived ship” and when laytime begins.
- Key in determining commencement of demurrage.
5. Pyrene Co Ltd v Scindia Navigation Co Ltd
- Addressed freight liability and risk transfer.
- Established that contractual terms govern freight obligations.
6. Dampskibsselskabet Norden A/S v Andre & Cie SA
- Clarified liability for dead freight and cargo shortfall.
- Emphasized strict enforcement of charterparty terms.
7. The Mexico I
- Distinguished between demurrage and damages for detention.
- Owners may claim damages beyond demurrage in exceptional cases.
5. Types of Claims in Disputes
(i) Freight Claims
- Non-payment of agreed freight
- Disputes over freight calculation
(ii) Demurrage Claims
- Delay beyond laytime
- Wrong calculation of laytime
(iii) Dead Freight Claims
- Charterer fails to supply full cargo
(iv) Detention Claims
- Damages for delay not covered by demurrage clause
6. Role of Arbitration
Most freight and demurrage disputes are resolved through arbitration under:
- London Maritime Arbitrators Association
- Singapore Chamber of Maritime Arbitration
Advantages:
- Expertise in maritime law
- Faster resolution
- Confidential proceedings
7. Practical Issues in Freight & Demurrage Disputes
(a) Documentation
- Statement of Facts (SOF)
- Notice of Readiness (NOR)
- Time sheets
(b) Calculation Complexity
- Interruptions (weather, strikes)
- Laytime exceptions
(c) Contract Drafting
- Ambiguous clauses lead to disputes
- Poorly defined laytime terms
8. Preventive Measures
- Clear drafting of charterparty clauses
- Proper documentation of delays
- Accurate laytime calculations
- Inclusion of dispute resolution clauses
Conclusion
Disputes over freight and demurrage claims revolve around contractual interpretation, timing, and responsibility for delays. Courts and arbitral tribunals consistently emphasize strict adherence to charterparty terms, especially regarding laytime and demurrage. Landmark cases like Aktieselskabet Reidar v Arcos Ltd and The Bonde have shaped the principles governing these disputes, making clarity in drafting and documentation essential for avoiding costly litigation.
RELATED Blog
comments