Biotechnology Robotic Surgery Regulation In Russia.

1. Introduction

Biotechnology robotic surgery is an advanced medical technology in which robotic systems, computer-assisted instruments, artificial intelligence (AI), imaging technologies and specialised surgical software assist medical professionals in performing surgical procedures.

In Russia, robotic surgery is increasingly relevant to:

Robotic-assisted laparoscopic surgery.

Robot-assisted urological and prostate surgery.

Robotic cardiovascular surgery.

Neurosurgical robotic systems.

AI-assisted surgical planning.

Remote-controlled robotic surgery (telesurgery).

Autonomous surgical technologies.

Biotechnological integration of robotics with regenerative medicine.

Russia does not have one comprehensive federal statute exclusively governing robotic surgery. Instead, robotic surgery is regulated through a combination of healthcare legislation, medical-device registration requirements, medical-activity licensing, patient-consent rules, professional standards, personal-data legislation and civil and criminal liability.

The principal legislation is Federal Law No. 323-FZ of 21 November 2011, On the Fundamentals of Health Protection of Citizens in the Russian Federation.

Other important legal instruments include:

Federal Law No. 323-FZ on healthcare.

Federal Law No. 99-FZ on licensing of certain types of activities.

Federal Law No. 152-FZ on personal data.

Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.

Government Resolution No. 1684 of 30 November 2024 on medical-device registration.

Government Resolution No. 852 of 1 June 2021 concerning licensing of medical activities.

The central legal question is whether responsibility for an injury caused during robotic surgery belongs to the surgeon, hospital, manufacturer, software developer or another responsible participant.

Russian law generally approaches this question through existing legal rules on human responsibility, medical negligence, defective products and organisational liability.

2. Constitutional and legislative foundations

The constitutional foundation of robotic surgery regulation is the protection of human life, health and dignity.

Relevant constitutional provisions include:

Article 20: Right to life.

Article 21: Protection of human dignity.

Article 41: Right to health protection and medical assistance.

Article 46: Judicial protection of rights.

Article 41 is particularly important because technological innovation cannot eliminate the patient's fundamental right to safe and legally compliant medical treatment.

For example, a hospital cannot justify an avoidable surgical injury simply by arguing that robotic surgery is an experimental or technologically advanced treatment.

The medical institution must ensure that the technology is appropriately authorised, that qualified professionals operate it and that patients receive legally adequate information.

3. Federal Law No. 323-FZ and robotic surgery

Federal Law No. 323-FZ is the principal legislative framework governing robotic surgical procedures.

Several provisions are particularly significant.

A. Article 20: Informed voluntary consent

Article 20 requires informed voluntary consent before medical intervention.

Patients must receive accessible information concerning:

The purpose of the operation.

The proposed surgical technique.

The use of robotic equipment.

Associated medical risks.

Alternative treatment methods.

Possible complications.

Expected results.

This provision is important because patients may mistakenly believe that robotic surgery is entirely autonomous.

Hospitals should therefore explain whether the robot is controlled by a surgeon, whether AI software assists decision-making and whether remote operation is involved.

Legal significance: Consent to ordinary surgery should not automatically be treated as adequate consent to materially different robotic procedures if the patient has not been properly informed about the relevant method and risks.

minzdrav.gov.ru+1

B. Article 37: Medical procedures and standards

Article 37 establishes the framework for organising and delivering medical assistance according to applicable procedures and standards.

Robotic surgery must therefore be integrated into the applicable medical-care requirements.

Hospitals should consider:

Clinical indications.

Appropriate patient selection.

Surgical protocols.

Equipment suitability.

Infection-control procedures.

Post-operative monitoring.

Emergency conversion to conventional surgery.

A hospital should not introduce a robotic system without considering whether its use is clinically justified and consistent with applicable medical requirements.

minzdrav.gov.ru

C. Article 38: Medical devices

Article 38 is one of the most important provisions for robotic surgery.

A robotic surgical system can fall within the statutory definition of a medical device because the definition includes medical equipment, instruments, accessories and specialised software used for medical purposes.

Consequently, relevant robotic equipment and associated medical software may require state registration.

The responsible authority is the Federal Service for Surveillance in Healthcare (Roszdravnadzor).

The registration process concerns the quality, safety and effectiveness of medical devices.

minzdrav.gov.ru+1

D. Article 73: Responsibilities of medical professionals

Article 73 establishes obligations of medical and pharmaceutical professionals.

Medical professionals must:

Work within their professional qualifications.

Follow applicable legal requirements.

Maintain professional competence.

Observe medical confidentiality.

Comply with professional duties.

A surgeon cannot automatically avoid responsibility by claiming that the robotic system made the surgical decision.

If the surgeon improperly operates the system, ignores warnings or fails to respond appropriately to complications, personal liability may arise.

minzdrav.gov.ru

E. Article 79: Responsibilities of medical organisations

Article 79 establishes important obligations of medical organisations.

These include organising medical activities in accordance with applicable legislation, ensuring appropriate medical assistance and providing patients with reliable information.

For robotic surgery, the hospital's responsibilities include appropriate equipment management, staff preparation and organisational safety.

Consultant Plus

F. Article 98: Liability in healthcare

Article 98 establishes responsibility for violations of rights in healthcare and harm caused to life or health during medical assistance.

Medical organisations and medical professionals may face liability under the applicable legislation.

Importantly, compensation by the medical organisation does not automatically exclude the possibility of separate liability for a medical professional.

minzdrav.gov.ru+1

4. Registration and approval of robotic surgical systems

Intuitive | DE | Hersteller der da Vinci und Ion Systeme

 

 

Da Vinci Operationstechnik

 

 

国产达芬奇Xi手术系统 - 直观复星 - IntuitiveFosun

 

9

 

Robotic surgical systems are subject to the Russian medical-device regulatory framework.

Government Resolution No. 1684 of 30 November 2024 establishes the rules for state registration of medical devices.

It became effective on 1 March 2025 and replaced the previous general registration framework under Resolution No. 1416.

The rules cover medical devices and relevant accessories, including specialised software.

The registration authority is Roszdravnadzor.

roszdravnadzor.gov.ru+1

Important compliance requirements

Regulatory requirementLegal significance
State registrationEstablishes eligibility for lawful circulation
Technical documentationDescribes intended use and device characteristics
Safety assessmentEvaluates potential risks
Clinical evaluationSupports safety and effectiveness
Software documentationAddresses relevant software functionality
Post-market monitoringIdentifies problems after market entry

A robotic surgical platform must be assessed according to its actual intended medical use.

For example, a system designed for surgeon-controlled laparoscopic procedures cannot automatically be used as an autonomous surgical system merely because its software has advanced capabilities.

Regulatory changes in 2026

Federal Law No. 304-FZ of 31 July 2025 introduced amendments relating to the registration certificate, effective from 1 March 2026.

Government Resolution No. 1206 of 13 August 2025 also amended the registration rules.

These developments are relevant to manufacturers introducing robotic medical equipment into Russia.

imdrf.org+1

5. Licensing of hospitals and robotic surgery centres

Robotic surgery cannot be legally separated from the licensing requirements applicable to medical activity.

Federal Law No. 99-FZ governs licensing of specified activities, while Government Resolution No. 852 of 1 June 2021 establishes the relevant licensing framework for medical activities.

A hospital providing robotic surgery must ensure that its medical licence covers the relevant medical activities.

Important compliance areas include:

Appropriate medical premises.

Qualified surgical personnel.

Properly maintained robotic equipment.

Appropriate anaesthesia and intensive-care facilities.

Emergency-response arrangements.

Compliance with applicable medical-care procedures.

Example: A private hospital purchases a sophisticated robotic surgical system but does not have the appropriate licensed medical activity or qualified surgical personnel. The purchase of the equipment alone does not authorise the hospital to provide the corresponding surgical services.

6. Legal regulation of robotic surgeons and artificial intelligence

High-Volume Robotic Surgery in China: The Safety Advantage

 

 

medbridgenz.com

The legal position becomes more complicated when robotic surgical systems incorporate artificial intelligence.

Three operational categories should be distinguished.

Category 1: Surgeon-controlled robotic surgery

The surgeon controls the robotic instruments through a specialised console.

The robot performs movements under the surgeon's control.

Category 2: AI-assisted robotic surgery

Artificial intelligence helps with imaging, anatomical identification, surgical planning and instrument guidance.

The surgeon remains responsible for clinical decisions within the applicable professional and legal framework.

Category 3: Autonomous robotic surgery

The system independently performs some or all surgical actions without continuous direct human control.

This raises more complicated questions about the legal allocation of responsibility.

Who is responsible when an AI surgical robot causes injury?

Responsible partyPotential legal responsibility
SurgeonNegligent operation or failure to respond to risks
HospitalOrganisational negligence and unsafe medical services
ManufacturerDefective equipment or inadequate safety information
Software developerPotential liability for defective software or negligent development
Maintenance providerNegligent servicing or equipment maintenance
Medical supervisorFailure to provide appropriate supervision

The applicable responsibility depends on the facts, the contractual relationships, the nature of the defect and the causal connection with the injury.

Can a surgical robot be criminally prosecuted?

Under the general principles of Russian criminal law, a robot is not a criminally responsible person.

Article 19 of the Criminal Code establishes the requirements concerning criminal responsibility of individuals.

Therefore, criminal responsibility must be considered in relation to identifiable human actors who satisfy the relevant statutory requirements.

A robot cannot simply be treated as a criminal defendant because its software caused an injury.

This does not mean that robotic technology is outside criminal law. It means that the investigation must identify the responsible human conduct and establish the necessary elements of an offence.

7. Civil liability for injuries caused by robotic surgery

Civil liability is a central part of Russian robotic surgery regulation.

The principal provisions are found in the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

A. Article 1064: General liability for harm

Article 1064 establishes the general principle that harm caused to another person must be compensated by the person responsible, subject to the statutory conditions and applicable defences.

Suppose a robotic surgical system causes serious internal injury because the hospital failed to arrange proper maintenance.

The patient may seek compensation based on the relevant evidence of negligence, causation and damage.

B. Article 1068: Liability for employees

Article 1068 concerns liability for harm caused by employees in the performance of their employment duties.

This provision is particularly important where a surgeon or other hospital employee negligently operates robotic equipment.

A medical organisation may therefore face civil liability for conduct attributable to its employees.

C. Article 1095: Harm caused by defects in goods, work or services

Article 1095 provides a framework for compensation for harm caused by defects in goods, work or services.

This provision may be relevant where a defective robotic instrument, software component or medical service causes patient injury.

The legal requirements must be assessed in conjunction with the other provisions of the Civil Code.

D. Article 1100: Non-pecuniary harm

Article 1100 identifies circumstances in which compensation for moral harm is payable irrespective of fault.

Its application depends on the particular legal ground and facts of the claim.

Article 151 is also relevant to compensation for moral harm.

Practical example

A patient undergoes robotic prostate surgery. During the operation, a defective robotic instrument causes an injury.

The investigation identifies three possible failures:

The manufacturer supplied a defective instrument.

The hospital failed to conduct the required technical checks.

The surgeon continued operating despite an equipment warning.

Depending on the evidence, the patient may have claims involving the manufacturer, medical organisation and other responsible parties.

The existence of several potential defendants does not automatically establish that all are legally liable.

8. Criminal liability for robotic surgery accidents

Russian criminal law may become relevant when robotic surgery causes death or serious injury through legally punishable conduct.

The following provisions deserve attention.

Criminal Code provisionRelevant legal issue
Article 109Causing death by negligence
Article 118Causing serious harm to health by negligence
Article 238Production, storage, transportation or sale of goods and provision of services that fail to meet safety requirements, subject to the statutory elements
Article 293Negligence by qualifying officials

Article 109: Death by negligence

Where a patient dies because of negligent medical conduct, Article 109 may become relevant.

For example, a surgeon may be investigated if a failure to respond to a known robotic-system malfunction contributed to a patient's death.

However, the prosecution must establish the required elements of the offence.

Article 118: Serious harm by negligence

This provision may apply where negligent conduct causes serious harm to a patient's health.

A robotic surgical injury does not automatically establish criminal liability.

Medical evidence, causation and the applicable criminal-law requirements must be established.

Article 238: Safety violations

Article 238 may be relevant where the statutory requirements concerning unsafe goods or services are satisfied.

For example, an investigation might examine whether a medical institution provided a service that failed to meet legally applicable safety requirements.

It should not be assumed that every unsuccessful operation constitutes an Article 238 offence.

Article 293: Official negligence

Article 293 may be relevant where a qualifying official fails to perform official duties properly and the statutory consequences are established.

For instance, an official responsible for hospital safety systems might be investigated following serious organisational failures.

9. Case laws and judicial developments

An important research distinction is necessary here: there is a difference between a judicial decision directly involving robotic surgery and a general medical-liability judgment that provides principles applicable to robotic surgery.

Russian judicial decisions specifically determining liability for injuries caused by autonomous surgical robots remain limited in the publicly identifiable authorities reviewed for this subject.

The following authorities and legal materials are relevant.

Case 1. UROGIN+ LLC v Moscow Regional FAS (2026)

Directly relevant robotic-surgery procurement decision

Court: Ninth Arbitration Court of Appeal.

Date: 7 May 2026.

Case No.: A40-340576/2025.

Decision No.: 09АП-15734/26.

Facts

The dispute concerned the procurement of a robotic surgical system by a major medical centre.

The procurement specifications required the equipment to possess remote-operation or telesurgery functionality.

The claimant challenged the legality of the procurement requirements, arguing that the technical specifications could restrict competition.

Judicial reasoning

The appellate court upheld the relevant procurement position.

The court accepted the medical centre's justification for requiring the remote-operation capability, taking into account the technical evidence and the particular requirements of the medical institution.

The absence of registered equivalent equipment was relevant to the assessment of the specialised procurement requirement.

Legal significance

This decision is important for three reasons:

Hospitals may establish specialised technical requirements for robotic surgical systems when properly justified.

Remote surgical functionality can be a legitimate feature of a medical-equipment procurement.

Procurement legality and medical-device registration are separate regulatory questions.

Application to robotic surgery regulation

A hospital purchasing robotic surgical technology must comply with procurement law while ensuring that its equipment meets applicable healthcare and medical-device requirements.

Source: Ninth Arbitration Court of Appeal, Decision No. 09АП-15734/26.

Case 2. Chernykh: Robots in Surgery – Who Should Be Held Criminally Responsible (2023)

Russian legal scholarship

Author: Evgeniya E. Chernykh.

Publication: Legal Science and Practice: Journal of Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia.

Year: 2023.

Issue: 3 (63).

Pages: 80–84.

DOI: 10.36511/2078-5356-2023-3-80-84.

Subject of the research

The article directly examines the question of criminal responsibility when a patient suffers harm from an operation performed by a surgical robot.

It discusses the legal status of the robot as a potential subject of criminal responsibility.

Legal significance

The research raises an important distinction between:

The robot as a technological instrument.

The surgeon controlling the system.

The manufacturer responsible for its design.

The medical organisation responsible for its use.

Other persons whose conduct may contribute to an accident.

The research is particularly relevant to the debate over whether existing criminal-law concepts are sufficient to address increasingly autonomous medical technologies.

Important qualification: This is an academic legal publication, not a court judgment. It must not be cited as an established judicial precedent.

Source: Chernykh, Robots in Surgery: Who Should Be Held Criminally Responsible (2023).

Case 3. General medical-device registration and regulatory authority

Roszdravnadzor – State Registration of Medical Devices

This is an administrative regulatory framework rather than a judicial case.

Article 38 of Federal Law No. 323-FZ requires registration of medical devices under the applicable registration procedure.

Roszdravnadzor exercises registration and oversight functions.

Legal significance

The framework establishes that a medical robotic system cannot be treated simply as ordinary industrial machinery when it is intended for medical use.

Its medical-device status brings it within a specialised regulatory system.

Source: Roszdravnadzor – State Registration of Medical Devices.

Case 4. Article 20 informed-consent framework under Federal Law No. 323-FZ

This is a statutory legal authority, not a named court judgment.

Article 20 requires informed voluntary consent based on adequate information about medical intervention, its methods, associated risks, alternatives and consequences.

Application

If a hospital fails to explain material risks of robotic surgery, the patient's consent may become a significant issue in subsequent civil litigation.

For example, a patient who agrees to surgery believing that the robot is completely autonomous, when in fact the system is surgeon-controlled or AI-assisted, may raise questions about the adequacy of the information provided.

Source: Article 20, Federal Law No. 323-FZ.

10. Telemedicine and remote robotic surgery

UK’s first robotic surgery takes place as London surgeon operates on prostate cancer patient Paul Buxton 2,400km away in Gibraltar | The Independent

 

 

independent.co.uk

Remote robotic surgery creates additional legal questions because the surgeon and patient may be located in different places.

For example, a surgeon in Moscow may operate a robotic system installed in a hospital in another Russian region.

Relevant legal issues include:

Identification and qualifications of the operating surgeon.

Licensing of the medical organisations involved.

Reliability of telecommunications.

Cybersecurity of surgical equipment.

Responsibility for interruptions in connectivity.

Emergency intervention when remote control fails.

Patient consent to the remote surgical method.

Article 36.2 of Federal Law No. 323-FZ establishes the framework for telemedicine technologies.

However, telemedicine authorisation should not be interpreted as blanket permission for every form of remote robotic surgery. The specific procedure must satisfy the applicable medical and licensing requirements.

11. Personal data and cybersecurity in robotic surgery

Robotic surgical systems may process highly sensitive medical information.

Such information can include:

Patient medical records.

Surgical video recordings.

Anatomical imaging.

Biometric information.

AI-generated surgical assessments.

Remote-operation records.

Post-operative monitoring information.

Federal Law No. 152-FZ on Personal Data is particularly relevant.

Article 10 establishes special protection for personal data relating to health.

Article 19 concerns measures to ensure the security of personal data.

Hospitals must also consider Article 13 of Federal Law No. 323-FZ, which protects medical confidentiality.

Example: A robotic surgery company transfers surgical recordings to a foreign cloud server for AI training without the necessary legal basis.

This may raise questions concerning medical confidentiality, personal-data processing, cross-border data transfers and applicable data-localisation requirements.

12. Clinical trials and experimental robotic surgery

Robotic surgery technologies may undergo clinical evaluation before they are introduced into routine medical practice.

The legal framework includes:

Federal Law No. 323-FZ.

Article 38 concerning medical devices.

Applicable medical-device registration rules.

Government Resolution No. 1684 of 2024.

Relevant clinical-investigation and ethical requirements.

A manufacturer developing a new robotic surgical platform must establish the necessary safety and effectiveness evidence.

Particular attention is required where the system introduces:

Autonomous instrument movement.

AI-based tissue recognition.

New surgical navigation technology.

Experimental robotic implants.

New remote surgical capabilities.

An experimental surgical system must not be treated as an ordinary registered medical device merely because it has been successfully tested in a laboratory.

13. Manufacturer responsibility and defective robotic equipment

Manufacturers have an important role in maintaining the safety of robotic surgical systems.

Potential defects include:

Type of defectExample
Mechanical defectRobotic arm moves unexpectedly
Software defectIncorrect anatomical identification
Sensor defectFailure to detect instrument position
Communication defectDelayed transmission of surgical commands
Design defectUnsafe instrument configuration
Information defectInadequate safety warnings

The relevant legal analysis may involve:

Civil Code Article 1064.

Civil Code Article 1095.

Consumer-protection legislation, where applicable.

Federal Law No. 323-FZ.

Medical-device registration and safety requirements.

A manufacturer may face liability where the evidence establishes a legally relevant product defect and the necessary causal connection with the patient's injury.

14. Regulatory challenges in Russian robotic surgery

Russia faces several important legal and regulatory challenges.

1. Autonomous surgical decision-making

Existing legal rules generally allocate responsibility to identifiable human actors and organisations. Autonomous surgical decision-making makes the allocation of responsibility more difficult.

2. Lack of specific robotic-surgery legislation

The existing healthcare framework regulates medical devices and medical activities, but does not comprehensively address every issue arising from autonomous surgical robots.

3. Surgeon training and certification

The appropriate level of robotic-surgery training and competency assessment is essential for patient safety.

4. Software-related errors

It may be difficult to distinguish between a surgeon's operational error, software malfunction and a defective system design.

5. Cross-border telesurgery

Remote operations may involve different hospitals, manufacturers, software providers and telecommunications networks.

6. Patient consent

Patients need meaningful information about the extent of robotic assistance and the limitations of the technology.

7. Cybersecurity

A cyberattack affecting surgical instruments or operating-room systems could create direct risks to patient safety.

15. Recommendations for improving Russian robotic surgery regulation

Several reforms could strengthen the Russian legal framework.

Proposed reformExpected regulatory benefit
Dedicated robotic surgery legislationClearer legal responsibilities
Robotic surgeon competency standardsImproved professional accountability
AI surgical software certificationBetter technological safety
Mandatory incident reportingStronger adverse-event monitoring
Autonomous surgery safeguardsProtection against uncontrolled operations
Specific robotic surgery consent formsImproved patient autonomy
Cybersecurity standardsProtection of surgical systems
Manufacturer accountability rulesBetter compensation and safety mechanisms
Remote surgery regulationsClearer cross-regional responsibility

A particularly important reform would be a statutory framework allocating responsibility between the surgeon, hospital, manufacturer and software developer according to their respective control, duties and contribution to the injury.

16. Conclusion

Robotic surgery regulation in Russia is based primarily on Federal Law No. 323-FZ, medical-device registration rules, medical licensing requirements, civil liability principles and criminal law.

Article 20 protects patient autonomy through informed consent. Article 38 establishes the medical-device regulatory framework. Articles 73 and 79 address professional and institutional responsibilities, while Article 98 provides the healthcare liability framework.

The 2026 UROGIN+ procurement decision is a particularly relevant judicial development because it concerns the technical requirements of robotic surgical equipment and remote-operation functionality.

The 2023 research by Evgeniya Chernykh is also important because it examines the difficult question of criminal responsibility when surgical robots cause patient injury.

Nevertheless, a clear distinction must be maintained: the procurement decision is a judicial authority, whereas the Chernykh article is academic research. Neither establishes a comprehensive judicial doctrine governing injuries caused by autonomous surgical robots.

Ultimately, the major legal challenge for Russia is ensuring that technological advancement in robotic surgery does not weaken patient rights, medical accountability or the fundamental protection of human life.

17. Important legal references and research sources

Legal authoritySubject
Russian Constitution, Articles 20, 21, 41 and 46Fundamental rights
Federal Law No. 323-FZ (2011)Healthcare regulation
Federal Law No. 99-FZ (2011)Licensing
Federal Law No. 152-FZ (2006)Personal-data protection
Government Resolution No. 1684 (2024)Medical-device registration
Government Resolution No. 852 (2021)Medical-activity licensing
Civil Code, Articles 1064, 1068, 1095 and 1100Civil liability
Criminal Code, Articles 109, 118, 238 and 293Criminal liability

Further reading:

Federal Law No. 323-FZ – Russian Ministry of Health.

Government Resolution No. 1684 – Medical Device Registration Rules.

UROGIN+ LLC v Moscow Regional FAS – 2026.

Chernykh (2023) – Robots in Surgery: Who Should Be Held Criminally Responsible.

Roszdravnadzor – Medical Device Registration.

Academic qualification: This is a research-oriented legal explanation based on the identifiable legislative framework and judicial materials available as of 18 November 2026. It is not a substitute for checking the latest consolidated Russian legislation and complete court judgments before legal citation or litigation use.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT